Obviously a hot topic at university today; it was interesting to hear comments from college kids (inc Wesley), Village kids and general university population.
Okay, wow so I feel pretty embroiled in all this. (Just for clarification's sake I am a college student) . I know the person 'Aly' well, same contributor to the Cleo Magazine and on the ACA. Both stories are by the same person. So it is one person's perspective. I actually do wonder if Cleo did really crash these college parties too btw-just the logistics of how they would have gotten in I am sketchy on.
I don't believe they are sham institutions-for some of us they serve a really valuable purpose. It is a nice interim for those that move many hours away from home (often international students and students from other states) and academic support via tutorial programs. It offers a support network that would be completely non existant for some students otherwise. Often good for students who train at SUSF for sport too. Selection is heavily focused on academics and ECs-and there are often scholarship opportunities for students.
I feel that we have to be careful to brush all the colleges with the same brush. I know for my college, that we were never forced into an O week ritual or initiation. Every activity was under the proviso of "if you want to". Some of the people at my college don't even drink at all. There were also dry events offered during the week, it was not open bar at every event, obviously as there were u18 events for the underagers. Some alcoholic events went by way of pre paid drink cards etc.
However, I'm not going to shy away from discussion of the topic at hand here. As whenever, I am a part of anything, I will endeavour to make it a better place. I won't shy away from the tough issues and I will be completely honest. And really I'm still on an early stage anthropological study thing into this whole college culture-and it's pretty interesting considering all I had heard last year leading up to going here. I will be able to more solidly form an opinion after greater experience with the college calendar.
I cannot speak for all elements of the article as many of the college events are X with college Y one night in O week, then College X and College Z have breakfast this morning together etc. and this is from a particular college fresher's perspective. I've heard many differing recounts of some of the college events. For the events I was at, I can vouch that particularly the ACA story is completely overblown. I did not witness some of the reputed statements made in the article at the events I was at, like the Foam Party(saw no groping) or one of the Paul's parties(there's no mystery punch, all drinks are served through the bar). Most of that footage is schoolies stock footage and some of it just from the general University Wonderland party. I was not at the Wesley breakfast on the 28th but did attend one of the other ones during the week(only male Wesley students were at this one). It was probably the event I saw the most evidence of a 'hazing' but not to the level described in the article.
There are issues that come up in college, nowhere is perfect-however I think these are more endemic in society and they shouldn't just be pinned on these 'elitist' USYD colleges which seem to be the easy target for media. Drinking culture exists in the general university and wider community, there are RSA efforts at college to manage this. I would be really loathe to experience sexism at college, and will ardently speak out about it if I see it occur. Unfortunately sexism is something prevalent in the whole of society, it is not something ingrained into a college if it were to occur. There's other aspects of college that strike me that I would like to move forward for change, firstly how some particular colleges are quite heavily Sydney populated. To me, it really defeats the purpose of a college if you live 10-15 mins away from the university.
It is an interesting comparison to try and compare the culture to say the Melbourne residential colleges, ANU residential colleges and say like UNSW, Uni Of Newcastle etc. Often you find that the demographic and culture in the colleges can differ diversely from one another on the same campus. I'd definitely love to (and will) discuss how my friends found their experiences at other university's college and see what kind of culture operated at each one. I looked fairly thoroughly into colleges at other three universities, but hearing first hand experience is always the most interesting way to examine and learn. I think the key principle with college orientation and events through the year is a policy of having things in good fun and most importantly, voluntary participation. My college O week experience was fantastic, and from what I gather the majority would agree, but there's always growth to be had and rational/truthful discussion to be had. The Cleo Magazine and ACA story are a sham of journalism though-I wouldn't trust their journalistic integrity as far as I could throw it.