kkk579
hello
centripetal acceleration is always towards the centre of the motion and clearly B is pointing towards the centre so why is it A? or does this only apply to perfectly circular orbits cos this one is more of an ellipse
-
Finished your HSC? Check out our University Discussion, Non-School forums or help out next year's HSC students! -
YOU can help the next generation of students in the community! Share your trial papers and notes on our Notes & Resources page
why not B (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter kkk579
- Start date
You are correct that the force should point to the centre in uniform circular motion. But consider where this force would be coming from in the scenario of B. It cannot come from nowhere. The only force that makes sense here is gravity, which would act toward the centre of Earth. It's kinda a trick question, cause its not actually ucm, the sattelite would eventually fall out of the path shown (I think).
kkk579
hello
Why would it fall out of the path? That only happens when its velocity decreases
Cause the force is not acting in the way that will keep it in ucm, and consequently uniform velocity. Velocity will only be maintained if the force acts to the centre. Of course I could be wrong but it doesn’t really matter for this question.
kkk579
hello
Tbh idk what ur tryna say but i js searched it up and its says for an object orbitting another object in an ellipse motion the acceleration doesnt act towards the centre of the ellipse but rather the object its orbitting
Average Boreduser
Rising Renewal
um girlie
, its not in ucm. The net ACCELERATION is the gravitational force. since its not in circular motion, the acceleration is from the force (generally net here since no other forces acting on the satellite) from the planet.
kkk579
hello
Yeah but its not circular motion either so acceleration wouldnt be towards the middle but towards the mass its orbitingum girlie
Average Boreduser
Rising Renewal
yea... hence A right?
kkk579
hello
Yeah i just didnt originally know that if the object doesnt orbit the central mass in a perfect circle then acceleration doesnt necessarily act towards the centre
wizzkids
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jul 13, 2016
- Messages
- 332
- Gender
- Undisclosed
- HSC
- 1998
It is not uniform circular motion (UCM). The orbit of the satellite is an ellipse. An ellipse is a stable orbit. The object is not going to crash.
The force that keeps the two objects gravitationally bound together is the gravitational attraction vector that always points towards the centre of mass of each object. The correct answer is (A).
In general all objects in orbit usually have elliptical orbits. It is very rare to find a perfectly circular orbit, but the NSW Physics syllabus says we can discuss elliptical orbits only in a qualitative sense, not quantitatively.
The force that keeps the two objects gravitationally bound together is the gravitational attraction vector that always points towards the centre of mass of each object. The correct answer is (A).
In general all objects in orbit usually have elliptical orbits. It is very rare to find a perfectly circular orbit, but the NSW Physics syllabus says we can discuss elliptical orbits only in a qualitative sense, not quantitatively.