2023 ATAR/HSC Marks (1 Viewer)

xoNat

don't worry, be happy
Joined
Apr 30, 2022
Messages
911
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2024
omfg dude. speaking of which on the day the atars came out and stuff matrix emailed me asking for my marks and i just ignored it
now today they were calling me and when i didn't answer my call they had the audacity to call my DAD 😭
Vultures
 

C_master

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 13, 2023
Messages
964
Location
Sydney
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2025
omfg dude. speaking of which on the day the atars came out and stuff matrix emailed me asking for my marks and i just ignored it
now today they were calling me and when i didn't answer my call they had the audacity to call my DAD 😭
Sure are desperate
 

011235

Active Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2021
Messages
207
Gender
Male
HSC
2023
Can someone please detail what drugs the markers were smoking to give me 1/4 for this question? anyone? thanks!
Your working out is fairly poor, but I can follow your solution quite fine.

Let's go through the marking criteria;

Calculates the correct z-value. While you did not notate what the z-value is, it is there; but some markers would argue you didn't actually say what the z-value is. Personally I would have given the mark but "technically" it's a bit dubious.
Finds the correct probability from the table; you notated the stem of the question to show this. I'd say this is valid, apart from writing 1.3=90.82%, which is an incorrect mathematical statement. Could have been set out better though.
Finds the correct proportion of the group of koalas. Again, you have this written down, but the setting out is very bad. 100=9.18% is an incorrect mathematical statement.
Provides correct solution; you have the answer, and the calculation from the proportion. I think you got this.

If I was marking harshly I would have given this a 2, one for proportion->answer and one for z-score->proportion less than. Your solution cannot be followed in a step by step order to the answer without knowing the steps you are doing. Markers give marks for mathematical reasoning and demonstrating mathematical ability; just writing down the numbers can be insufficient - that's what I think happened here.

While I'm interpolating your steps, the marker doesn't have the liberty to do so. I'd say the marker refused to "fill in the gaps" in the explanations in your answer. the only logical correct calculations in the answer that is relevant are the 400*9.18% and the z-score calculation, which doesn't fit cleanly into the marking criteria. While harsh, I do see the argument that that could be equivalent merit to 1/4...
 

standardfailure

New Member
Joined
Aug 9, 2023
Messages
19
Gender
Male
HSC
2023
because your working out is sorta garbage, they gave 1/4 because you had the correct answer and 0 for your working out. you can’t say 1.33 = -1.33 = 91.78% (or whatever it is you wrote), your equating a bunch of numbers together which makes no sense
1.3303 = ~~~ 1.33 = 90.82%
 

katiekms

Member
Joined
Jun 25, 2023
Messages
62
Location
Newcastle Area
Gender
Female
HSC
2024
l
Your working out is fairly poor, but I can follow your solution quite fine.

Let's go through the marking criteria;

Calculates the correct z-value. While you did not notate what the z-value is, it is there; but some markers would argue you didn't actually say what the z-value is. Personally I would have given the mark but "technically" it's a bit dubious.
Finds the correct probability from the table; you notated the stem of the question to show this. I'd say this is valid, apart from writing 1.3=90.82%, which is an incorrect mathematical statement. Could have been set out better though.
Finds the correct proportion of the group of koalas. Again, you have this written down, but the setting out is very bad. 100=9.18% is an incorrect mathematical statement.
Provides correct solution; you have the answer, and the calculation from the proportion. I think you got this.

If I was marking harshly I would have given this a 2, one for proportion->answer and one for z-score->proportion less than. Your solution cannot be followed in a step by step order to the answer without knowing the steps you are doing. Markers give marks for mathematical reasoning and demonstrating mathematical ability; just writing down the numbers can be insufficient - that's what I think happened here.

While I'm interpolating your steps, the marker doesn't have the liberty to do so. I'd say the marker refused to "fill in the gaps" in the explanations in your answer. the only logical correct calculations in the answer that is relevant are the 400*9.18% and the z-score calculation, which doesn't fit cleanly into the marking criteria. While harsh, I do see the argument that that could be equivalent merit to 1/4...
lol i know this is from a while ago, but he gave the correct answer right? don’t you get full marks for correct answer regardless of working out?
 

katiekms

Member
Joined
Jun 25, 2023
Messages
62
Location
Newcastle Area
Gender
Female
HSC
2024
usually correct answer is only one part of the marking scheme

ie no you won’t get full marks just for the answer in most large-mark questions
oh i see. maybe my school does it differently because our marking criteria is like this: e.g 3 mark question. 3 marks for correct answer. 2 marks for significant progress towards answer. 1 mark for any relevant information. is this completely different to how they do it in the hsc?
 

tgone

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2022
Messages
181
Gender
Male
HSC
2022
oh i see. maybe my school does it differently because our marking criteria is like this: e.g 3 mark question. 3 marks for correct answer. 2 marks for significant progress towards answer. 1 mark for any relevant information. is this completely different to how they do it in the hsc?
i tell this to all the students i tutor about once a lesson: the people that write the exam already know what the answer is, they just want to know that you know how to get there!
 

carrotsss

New Member
Joined
May 7, 2022
Messages
4,722
Gender
Male
HSC
2023
ahh okay that makes sense. but in that guys example he did do working out it was just a tiny bit unclear right? coupled with the right answer, should that not still get full marks?
a lot of his working was also just wrong and weird, like they were equating numbers that aren’t equal and stuff like that. hsc questions ask for a full correct solution not just a correct value. definitely harsh marking but not unreasonable
 

katiekms

Member
Joined
Jun 25, 2023
Messages
62
Location
Newcastle Area
Gender
Female
HSC
2024
a lot of his working was also just wrong and weird, like they were equating numbers that aren’t equal and stuff like that. hsc questions ask for a full correct solution not just a correct value. definitely harsh marking but not unreasonable
thanks for this! that makes sense
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top