Australian Idol 2006 (2 Viewers)

[tres bien]

Lisa's performance was a little weak, but I absolutely love her and her style!

I want to marry Dean. He's everything I want in a guy. I also had that feeling that he'd choose that song. I nearly collapsed when I heard he was going to sing it.

I want Ricky or Klancie to go. I don't mind if Lavina goes, but Ricky is first choice. I hate his eyebrows and his teeth.

Bobby has this freakishness about him. He's ... weird... and I like that about him. He's someone I wouldn't expect to see in Idol.

I like this year's top 12, except for Ricky.

 

[Guernica]

Bobby's too good for idol. I want him to be voted off so that he can be picked up by another record label and be allowed more freedom.

Same with Lisa.

They both are good enough for a record deal imo and they would be better off not winning idol.

 

[Sarah168]

Agreed, Guernica.

Lisa gave a weak performance yesterday but it's more to do with the fact that she doesn't want to preen herself up and prance about on the stage like a prat. But, that's the essence of Idol so I hope she goes far enough to be significantly close to a deal but not far enought to win. Though, this is looking unlikely right now anyway.

Same with Bobby. Ever since Kyle called him Side Show Bobby, that's all I can think of when I see him...

 

[*hopeful*]

i dont see the fuss about dean, sure his kinda cute in a 16yr old way, not that much of an awesome singer

 

[Sarah168]

Ok, I'm on my way to being the most prolific poster in this thread but whatever.

I'm getting over Dean. He's getting boring and I'm not sure how long he can live off the screaming girls and posters like Kyle said.

 

[iambored]

Dean is the type that you love initally, he has a great voice but not fantastic, great looks, good songs, but there are too many of his type out there, so he's also the type you get over quickly
i love ricky, but he reminds me of callea so he might get old a bit faster than he deserves to
i love regain, if she does good performances she can go far.
i also think lisa and bobby are very unique and so don't deserve to win idol, they can do better. but lisa is a bit young.

 

[Shell]

I am in love with the Irish guy. i dont watch it enough to know his name... but god i would love him to do the hunters and collectors song, throw your arms around me again, like he did at the top 24 performance thingos.

 

[Guernica]

And with Lisa, I much prefer when she's singing her own stuff.

If only they were all talented singer-songwriters.. then they could have an originals night.

 

[tasha1188]

OMG No not Joseph *cries* What is wrong with this country *angry face*

 

[$hiftyIceQueen]

^that was true..

i wanted josef to stay and lavina to go..he also performed better today then he did yesterday...

 

[Sarah168]

That's true with Joseph but although I don't like Lavina, I think her performance was pretty good if a little overdone.

What's up with Lisa?? During the group performance, she just slipped under the radar and in one of the last moments of the song when everybody was rallying to finish it off, her mouth was just shut. Gahhhh, come on Lisa!

 

[bubz :D]

Sorry guys.. but Bobby freaks me out I only saw up to the beginning of Lavina's performance and I think the best one was Damien's... I think people might start getting bored with his stuff, though. Lisa has a unique voice but can she show us what she can do with it?

 

[*hopeful*]

That's true with Joseph but although I don't like Lavina, I think her performance was pretty good if a little overdone.

What's up with Lisa?? During the group performance, she just slipped under the radar and in one of the last moments of the song when everybody was rallying to finish it off, her mouth was just shut. Gahhhh, come on Lisa!

Lol yeh i saw that bit, shes really out of it most of the time...

awww poor jospeh, he was so upset and i think reigan should have gone over him, i for sure thought it was her

 

[iambored]

I think Kyle made a rather insightful comment, even though he was booed for it, the fact that Joseph and Lavina didn't connect with the audience because they're shy and guarded, respectively.

what did he mean by guarded for lavina?

 

[*hopeful*]

^not letting her guard down, maybe not as much out there as others ?

:wave: iab

 

[ane_st]

I didnt like Lisa that much... I dont kno i just dont think shes as good as the others... As for Joseph... I thought he was really shy and couldnt perform to the best he actually can... Thats maybe why they voted for him... Yeah i dont like Reagan..

 

[Silver Persian]

Hah! I am so happy Joseph went. (I am so cruel )

I hope Lavina does a more likeable song next week because shes got a kickass voice. Everyone else sounded crap next to her in the group performance.

And why can Kyle call her fat so many times and nobody cares, but Dicko calls Paulini a little chubby once and it becomes a national scandal.

 

[Sarah168]

I generally like Kyle as a judge even though most of his comments are either superficial or basically just trashing them cos they sang something he didn't know and/or didn't like. It's different from Marcia's annoying constant praise and Mark's...well, craziness.

Lisa is just so lost without her guitar. When she's in her element (i.e Diamonds on the Inside), she is just awesome but otherwise ...

 

[iambored]

^not letting her guard down, maybe not as much out there as others ?

:wave: iab

:wave: hopeful
thanks for that, i only visit other forums/threads apart from mac every now and then

well i would definitely agree with that, moreso than people not connecting with joseph because he was shy (which i also agree with, but i think some of us were ready to see him become less shy). as i said before, i found lavina's performance quite boring because it was so normal

 

[ane_st]

I generally like Kyle as a judge even though most of his comments are either superficial or basically just trashing them cos they sang something he didn't know and/or didn't like. I

Its true.. His comments are extrememly superficial... However thats the first thing people notice about someone, their looks, so he's just commenting on how the 'real world' (so to speak) is going to view them...

And for what he comments on some songs is true... If he hasn't heard a song then the general public (or at least teens) may not know/heard that song before either....

I like Kyle's honesty and i think he is an excellent judge who does speak the truth instead of Marcia constantly telling them all that they're excellent.