B Ancient History (Honours) (1 Viewer)

jimjim

Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2004
Messages
47
Hey guys! I just went to the Macquarie Uni open day and I came across the ideal course! I'm really considering this course - anything ancient history is perfect! I was just wondering, are there many ppl here doing this? If so, do you recommdend it? Is it hard work?! Well, of course it is.. ANY uni course is hard work! hehe!

thanks ur comments in advance! :D

cheers,
jimmy!
 

AsyLum

Premium Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2002
Messages
15,899
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
N/A
Yes, PwarYuex would be the best source for this since he is basically doing one combined with law :)
 

Cyan_phoeniX

Active Member
Joined
Aug 16, 2003
Messages
1,639
Location
Sydney
Gender
Male
HSC
N/A
jimmyjojo said:
I am intrigued.. :p
yes. you should be. if anyone is going take the grand high chair of ancient history god of the world.. it will be rob. He will be here any moment now....



... any.... moment...
 
X

xeuyrawp

Guest
OMG! YESSS!!!!!!!! I CAN ANSWER A QUESTION! ecom141, anybody?

Firstly, have a look at teh course structure here.

Ok, well, Jimmy I do this course, and there are a few hidden things to note.

The obvious question worth answering is 'Why do this course over a BArts?' That is a good question. There are a few things that makes the BAncHist (hons) course worth doing rather than the BA:

1. You can do any ancient language in your first year (you can't in a BArts)- this includes Hieros, Greek, Latin, Classical Hebrew, and German for Special Purposes. I really would have liked to have done hieros this year, but I couldn't.

2. It gives you automatic admission to honours and certain other subjects. If you didn't know, an honours in a humanity generally means an extra year where you write a thesis and do a few seminars. Doing honours is really great and allows you to do a PhD straight after you graduate. The other subjects you can get admission to is the 'Masters Subjects'. These subjects are wide and many, but include specialised things, like Greek Coinage and Roman Papyrii. There are a tonne of these to chose from.

3. The same argument applies to 'why do a BMedia when you can do a BArts?' I have no idea what that argument is, but it has something to do with letting the uni focussing your study for you.

4. You still get 24 Credit Points (CPs) of electives- with me doing all my electives in HIST (Modern History) subjects. The AHST subjects are the Ancient History subs.

5. It's much more hard to transfer into the BAncHist (hons) degree from a BArts than vice versa. If you didn't know, Macquarie's great with transfers, with the general rule applying that, if you get the marks, you can transfer. To tranfer from a BArts to a BAncHist, you need marks slightly above average. To transfer from BAncHist to BArts, you need Passes. (Pass and above tends to be around 95-80% of the course; average (medium credit) seems to be around 50% of the courses)

There are, of course, a few cons-
1. If you start to like your electives a lot (like I did with HIST), you'll have to transfer to do a substantial amount of them. In my case, there are only a few HIST subjects that I want to do, so I can do a lot of these whilst doing the obligatory AHST subs.

2. If you don't get marks that I would call 'good', (ie, in the top 45-40% of the classes), you can't get admission to honours- you'll graduate withouth doing a thesis and the '(hons)' tag :(. Nb: if you're passionate about history, it's hard not to get good marks. A lot of people in your classes won't even like history, so you've already got an advantage.

3. You get a pretty well-structured degree, and you'll find that you do 3-4 (you do 4 subjects a semester maximum, usually) AHST subjects. I would say that my literacy skills are excellent, but 4 AHST subjects is a lot of work.

4. You can really do all the same subjects in the BAncHist(hons) taht you can do in a BA (Hons). You just can't initially do the languages. To gain entry to the Masters Subs, you just have to prove yourself and the lecturers will let you in.

NB: at Macquarie, there is a lot of flexibility. I say that you would do 3-4 AHST subs a semester, but you don't have to. You can extend your degree out, and as long as you don't wait till the cows come home, they won't care. You could do it part-time, and still have a casual job.

Also, the lecturers are reasonable, and if you prove yourself, they will let you take up more subjects that you may have only been able to do in the BAncHist(hons), you just have to show them that you work.

Furthermore, the subjects that you like and take up do not have to count towards your degree. You could go over 24 elective credit points and not get penalised- the worst you're doing is learning and making your degree go for a bit longer. Say if you do 24 credit points of electives and have done all your cores. You're thinking about graduating next year, but say 'I want a job and won't have time for the thesis. I need a car'. You could, if you want to, take up a few general units (languages, philosophy, sociology are all relevant to history, as is doing a general history unit) and delay your thesis by a semester.

Usually, I would have to sell you people on doing history, but thankfully that was already done by some sleak salesman at open day!

Did you have fun at open day, Jimmy? If you want to anything else, ask away :D

My honest recommendation would be to enrol in a Bachelor of Arts. That way, you can do different subjects if you like. You can also, in second year, concurrently enrol in a Diploma of Ancient Languages, which you could count a bunch of AHST language subjects towards.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
X

xeuyrawp

Guest
Bah, I just realised something important that you might have missed. If you haven't missed it, sorry to patronise.

All the subjects available in the BAncHist (bar the initial masters and languages) are available in the BArts degree. You don't go to different classes, you're all mixed up together. That's the way uni works.

Therefore, if you're in the BAncHist, you're doing as much work as someone doing exactly the same subjects in a BA.
 
X

xeuyrawp

Guest
miss_gtr said:
Could you tell me the difference in UAI cut off?)
86.00 for BA vs 86.15 for the BAncHist.

And in MQ is it easy to swap from DFEE to CSP after a year/semester?..(sorry to hijack this thread)
what?
 
X

xeuyrawp

Guest
miss_gtr said:
say i get in through domestic fee (DFEE) and i want to change back to CSP (hecs) ASAP.. is it hard to do that?
Couple of issues- 1. Macquarie rarely has different entry requirements for CSP vs DFEE courses. A fee BA and a HECS BA are both 86 UAI.

2. I don't think you 'change to CSP'. Those who want to pay outright just pay their HECS on the spot with a form. If you want to keep it on HECS, you just don't pay it. I don't think there's any paperwork- Macquarie's not a money-grabbing organisation like USyd.
 

taco man

don't know don't care
Joined
Jan 28, 2005
Messages
190
Location
boo rite behind you
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2005
I'd say that i like ancient history a lot, such that i'm considerin to do an arts course for it but one thing that concerns me are the lack of career opportunities . I had a talk to my careers advisor 2day n relly he said that u can either be an academist/historian, which is relly relly hard, or a techer/librarian/archivist/curator, etc. Wat would u say abt the career opportunities??
 

AsyLum

Premium Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2002
Messages
15,899
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
N/A
miss_gtr said:
Could you tell me the difference in UAI cut off?
And in MQ is it easy to swap from DFEE to CSP after a year/semester?..(sorry to hijack this thread)
MQ is for the first time next year releasing some DFEE places, the exact number and requirements are at this stage sketchy if not non existant.

PwarYuex said:
Couple of issues- 1. Macquarie rarely has different entry requirements for CSP vs DFEE courses. A fee BA and a HECS BA are both 86 UAI.

2. I don't think you 'change to CSP'. Those who want to pay outright just pay their HECS on the spot with a form. If you want to keep it on HECS, you just don't pay it. I don't think there's any paperwork- Macquarie's not a money-grabbing organisation like USyd.
She's referring to full fee entry, rather than full upfront HECS.

taco man said:
I'd say that i like ancient history a lot, such that i'm considerin to do an arts course for it but one thing that concerns me are the lack of career opportunities . I had a talk to my careers advisor 2day n relly he said that u can either be an academist/historian, which is relly relly hard, or a techer/librarian/archivist/curator, etc. Wat would u say abt the career opportunities??
Like i told the B Arts/B Science people asking the exact same question.

At MQ, you can major in B Arts in basically any aspect within the uni (save Law and other specific/recognition subjects) with a great option to do graduate/postgrad in another degree at the end of your 3 years. Now what this does is give you an advantage, 1000 people will hold a generic B Business. You hold a B Arts in Ancient History/Politics/Philosophy with a post grad Business or other. Now you have qualifications, as well as a B Arts degree which shows to the employer that you can think outside the square, that you aren't just another wheel in the machine. (This again is dependent upon your degree of choice, and i by no means know the full length of the B Bus degree and merely using it as an example.)

Otherwise, the degree could lead to a whole lot of things, teaching would probably be the most appealing option to people, or if you're good enough a historian. Degrees aren't limitations, they're accreditation, pieces of paper which we pay a shitload of money for, to tell people we know A, B, C. They do not guarantee a job.
 
X

xeuyrawp

Guest
taco man said:
I'd say that i like ancient history a lot, such that i'm considerin to do an arts course for it but one thing that concerns me are the lack of career opportunities . I had a talk to my careers advisor 2day n relly he said that u can either be an academist/historian, which is relly relly hard, or a techer/librarian/archivist/curator, etc. Wat would u say abt the career opportunities??
I have said this soooo many times that I'm considering writing an article on it and linking it.

There are a tonne of careers out there that have no formal training. A lot of data and information research analysts have done random things like history (which is, hands-down, the most research intensive subject of all time).

Your ability to form arguments and write, like, say if you did another humanity, will be improved so much that it won't be funny.

The fact is that there is a trend towards people having 'no idea', so they do arts. I think this is shifting towards business, but the basic idea is that BA grads were branded as idiots because of the quality of people that did it.

The hard line is that if you get good marks and are impressive, you could go work for the huge business that is our government, you could go on writing for any number of organisations, you could go do research for a business firm. My Egyptology tutor's friend recently graduated with a PhD in historical ethics- she now works for PriceWaterhouseCoopers as some sort of research director. Such a job cannot be prepared for apart from things that produce generic skills.

(god. when shall I write this article...?)

Finally, there's always the matter of happiness and the 'the road not taken' syndrome. 'If I do ancient history, my life will be ruined and I'll turn into a teacher!'. Can I ask how this is true? Say, for hypothetical's sake, that you do ancient history and graduate. That's 3 years of your life. If you want to go all money-focused, you can do a graduate law degree, business, or economics. Lest you actually like doing history and decide that academic life is for you.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Tabris

Member
Joined
Mar 16, 2004
Messages
806
Gender
Male
HSC
2004
Go for it...

A little bit of Suetonius (spelling?) Plutarch, thucydides, polybius, livius, homer, virgil, Dio, priscus, Jordannes, tacitus, Gibbons etc. is always useful, u feel more enlightened reading these classics than doing number crunching accounting...

Even though alot of us asians dont do AHST, I am thinking about doing B arts - Economics so i can add in some AHST units...

I usually spend my time reading the AHST books when i am tired of my ECFS work... A copy of any ancient roman history book is useful, keeps the accg stuff getting too much into your head
 
Last edited:
X

xeuyrawp

Guest
Tabris said:
Go for it...

A little bit of Suetonius (spelling?) Plutarch, thucydides, polybius, livius, homer, virgil, Dio, priscus, Jordannes, tacitus, Gibbons etc. is always useful, u feel more enlightened reading these classics than doing number crunching accounting...

Even though alot of us asians dont do AHST, I am thinking about doing B arts - Economics so i can add in some AHST units...

I usually spend my time reading the AHST books when i am tired of my ECFS work... A copy of any ancient roman history book is useful, keeps the accg stuff getting too much into your head
yay! Go arts :D
 
X

xeuyrawp

Guest
... said:
i'm asian

i'm doing a science degree

and i chose a history unit as an elective :cool:
Yeah, and you seemed to like it. So what's all this anti-history vibe that I can feel tingling through my fraun?
 

...

^___^
Joined
May 21, 2003
Messages
7,723
Location
somewhere inside E6A
Gender
Male
HSC
1998
haha

no bad vibe

i loved it to bits even though i struggled with getting good marks with the essays
wouldn't mind doing another history unit, but i might be inclined more to elec next yr
 
X

xeuyrawp

Guest
I wasn't saying the vibe was coming from you... I just sense it floating around :p
 
X

xeuyrawp

Guest
OMG.

*memo to self: don't bother writing a lot of helpful shit on bos, as newbs never come back to read it.*
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top