for and against?? (1 Viewer)

mandalay

cortigiana onesta
Joined
May 23, 2004
Messages
167
Gender
Female
HSC
2005
i was wondering if anyone has notes on or knows the arguments for and against different methods of protection:

* tariffs
* subsidies
* quotas
* voluntary export restraints
* embargoes
* export incentives
* local content rules

the problem is that i've looked in various textbooks and they only give definitions of those methods while i need advantages and especially disadvantages.

please help me out. any info whatsoever is greatly welcomed!!
 

Rekkusu

Currently: Away
Joined
Mar 6, 2005
Messages
1,113
Location
UNSW
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
* tariffs
* subsidies
* quotas
* voluntary export restraints
* embargoes
* export incentives
* local content rules

Well basically, all methods of protection both have advantages and disadvantages. The advantages would most likely be directed towards the economy imposing such protection levels, and disadvantages being those who must undergo the protection.

Briefly..

Tariffs:

Most widely used since its a tax imposed on imported goods, its a tax in which Domestic producers do not need to pay ---> Imported good price rises as a result, and leads to domestic producers gaining better competition. Governments are also happy of course! lol, since they get more money from foreign sources.. just like them imposing high income tax on us ;)

Anyhow, benefits are always coupled with costs, being that Tariffs or in fact any form of protection may or actually WILL cause retaliation from the other country, so generally if I say I'll put up protection on my goods, then that opposing country will say, "if u are putting up protection, I'll do the same.

Subsidies:

Generally economists prefer subsidies over tariffs for the government is spending money rather than receiving revenue, so it'll be reviewed alot. Additionally, because subsidies don't increase the price of goods in domestic economy, it further benefits consumers due to wider range of quality and cheaper goods -- > Lowered inflationary pressues.

The disadvantage being one which affects the global economy, which I'm sure you've heard of..being the CAP (european union's common agricultural policy) as well as America having such a policy, but forgot the name of it. Such policies will cause significant decreases in the global prices of that good, hence the main reason why Australia's agriculture despite its efficiency is unable to compete too much in the global market due to the lowered world price of such goods. (you can work it out through the supply and demand chart. )

Quotas:

Although the gov doesnt earn revenue from this, in reality, govts do charge importers with a licensing fee which once again contributes to higher market price of that good to be sold in the domestic economy.

The disadvantages are the same to tariffs.

* voluntary export restraints
* embargoes
* export incentives
* local content rules

These 4, are basically really easy, if you ever get stuck in answering a short answer question, just state that such measures of protection imposed on imported goods may cause a retaliatory effect of the country they are trading with.

Hope it has helped you..
 

Airazer

New Member
Joined
Mar 28, 2005
Messages
22
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2010
its in my textbook. what are u reading?
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top