Guy Sebastian (2 Viewers)

[hatty]

yeah guy was good
dont matter what his rank was in world idol
seeing that norwegian faggot came first (obviously it was rigged)

 

[bubz :D]

lol and has anyone heard of the norwegian hobbit since?

he wasn't that bad, but i don't think he was THAT good...
not as good as everyone was raving about, anyway

 

[hatty]

Originally posted by bubz
lol and has anyone heard of the norwegian hobbit since?

he wasn't that bad, but i don't think he was THAT good...
not as good as everyone was raving about, anyway

he certainly wasnt that bad but compared 2 the talent showcased that night, he shouldnt have won
they only reason he did win is because simon called him ugly.
which is also true but ppl felt sorry for the ugly bastard and voted

 

[iambored]

he was alright

they should have sang more than one song so we could get more of a feel for them

 

[christ_ine]

I thought he did reasonably well. It wasn't exactly the best version that he's sung, but still pretty good.

 

[Sarah168]

God, I absolutely despise that angels brought me here piece of shit in whatever way he sings it :angry:

I dont mind Guy so much but that song needs to piss off already

 

[santaslayer]

The CD version is the only good version. I don't like the afro, which was a significant contributing factor to him winning in the first place, IMO.
And danggg....wtf happened to jasmine? Americans can't vote!!!

 

[glycerine]

Originally posted by santaslayer
The CD version is the only good version. I don't like the afro, which was a significant contributing factor to him winning in the first place, IMO.
And danggg....wtf happened to jasmine? Americans can't vote!!!

WHAT?! You cannot honestly tell me that, last night at least, Jasmine was anywhere on par with the other two! She may be hot, but, as I've said, she's a singer, not a performer. The other two can at least do both, although I maintain that Fantasia's performance skills are far above Diana's, and I agree with Paula Abdul, Fantasia has moved beyond Idol status, she'll do great regardless of the result. In fact, she'll probably do better if she *doesn't* win, purely because she'll have more control over what she releases.

What I want to know is why Kelly Clarkson (ie, the first Idol) got decent songs like Miss Independant and... um... that other one... fuck, I can't remember the name... oh, that's right, Low. sure, they're not musical masterpieces, but you have to admit, they're high above shit like "Angels brought me here" and "All I need is you"... not to mention "Rise Up"

okay, */end rant*

 

[RUB!X]

^agree ...

 

[ay_caramba]

guy sebastian is sorta pretty, he has really pretty features

 

[PrettyNoose]

Originally posted by Mojoman
maybe because he is shit

aww good ol' moey

 

[Survivor39]

Originally posted by glycerine

What I want to know is why Kelly Clarkson (ie, the first Idol) got decent songs like Miss Independant and... um... that other one... fuck, I can't remember the name... oh, that's right, Low. sure, they're not musical masterpieces, but you have to admit, they're high above shit like "Angels brought me here" and "All I need is you"... not to mention "Rise Up"

okay, */end rant*

What about 'A Moment Like This' and 'Before Your Love'? They are masterpiece!

 

[iambored]

and why did kelly clarkson get good songs? she's american. simple as that. all our aussie stuff is crap because they go cheap. same with tv shows, movies and britain's things.

 

[Minai]

Originally posted by iambored
and why did kelly clarkson get good songs? she's american. simple as that. all our aussie stuff is crap because they go cheap. same with tv shows, movies and britain's things.

exactly what I was gonna say
its the same reason why aussie tv shows are complete crap when compared to american shows

 

[Sarah168]

yeah, but kelly clarkson sucks...in my books, her credibility is on par with bec cartwright

 

[Iunny]

we are so off topic but anywyas

^^no Kelly Clarkson knocking! I love her

 

[Fry]

Originally posted by iambored
and why did kelly clarkson get good songs? she's american. simple as that. all our aussie stuff is crap because they go cheap. same with tv shows, movies and britain's things.

i disagree. it depends on the songwriter. the very shitty 'Angels brought me here' was written by the Australian Idol pianist John Foreman and 'Rise up' was co-written by Mark Holden. very poor songwriters indeed.

i dont know many good aussie songwriters except Darren Hayes and Delta Goodrem. i am still amazed to this day of how she was able to write 'Not Me, Not I'. now that girl has talent!

 

[Collin]

Why's everyone saying that he isn't good? He's got some real talent. I don't like the kind of music he sings but he has talent, certainly more talent than Shannon Noll.

Originally posted by Minai
simon cowell was the one that actually wanted Guy there...thats gotta give u an ego boost

What? How did you find that out?

 

[Collin]

Originally posted by Reshie
where he is he...he releases like two songs(video clips)and disappears...and soo has Shannon Noll...and i hate music,sooo annoying

You hate music? lol

Originally posted by glycerine
amen, sista

there's a reason he came 11/14 on world idol

World Idol was a heap of crap. Too much bias, seriously. World Idol was nothing about talent.

 

[Sarah168]

obviously cos that norwegian retard won