Human Rights - Charter of Rights or Bill of Rights (1 Viewer)

[ChristopherLuu]

For those who did the CSSA trials, does anyone remember the 4 mark question about the bill of rights? Just wanted to see if anyone knows whats the difference from a bill of rights opposed to a charter of rights because apprantly according to marking criteria there is a difference

 

[Jongnie]

WHY IS THE ANSWER C !!!!!!!

 

[Exotic]

WHY IS THE ANSWER C !!!!!!!

Because there's no group of rights classified as "customary" or "human", and has nothing to do with self-determination. Land claims are property rights, the same way that you have rights over your own property, i.e. your house.

 

[SXCBEAST]

customary makes no sense. There is no human right specified to Indigenous people's owning property and self determination is a collective right giving Indigenous peoples a choice on who governs them. so its kind of an elimination process + the 1992 Mabo Case.

 

[Jongnie]

Because there's no group of rights classified as "customary" or "human", and has nothing to do with self-determination. Land claims are property rights, the same way that you have rights over your own property, i.e. your house.

):.

 

[Jongnie]

customary makes no sense. There is no human right specified to Indigenous people's owning property and self determination is a collective right giving Indigenous peoples a choice on who governs them. so its kind of an elimination process + the 1992 Mabo Case.

my book says "self-D~ has been defined by the UN as the right of people, especially indigenous people, to have at least partial control over their land." ... blah blah "self-d~ aims to allow minority groups the right to have some control over their land, while still being part of the broader nation"

edit : i thought self-determination was a human right?

 

[isenseven]

For those who did the CSSA trials, does anyone remember the 4 mark question about the bill of rights? Just wanted to see if anyone knows whats the difference from a bill of rights opposed to a charter of rights because apprantly according to marking criteria there is a difference

I think it was Outline ONE reason for and ONE reason against a charter of rights.

 

[4025808]

For those who did the CSSA trials, does anyone remember the 4 mark question about the bill of rights? Just wanted to see if anyone knows whats the difference from a bill of rights opposed to a charter of rights because apprantly according to marking criteria there is a difference

A Bill of Rights is the US version of a Charter of Rights in Australia. that's one difference that I can recall

 

[ChristopherLuu]

I think it was Outline ONE reason for and ONE reason against a charter of rights.

Hmm I did that but only got to two because I was talking about the Charter of Rights not the Bill of Rights