Is smacking a child ever acceptable? (6 Viewers)

[ay0_x]

adults learn from being hit too

if someone larger and stronger (so strong that fighting back is pointless and will end up in you getting hurt more), assaulted you for doing something wrong, and the there is no legal avenue to pursue, will you learn from your mistakes

this is essentially what is happening in the case of smacking a small child

it doesnt adversely affect the child

so it shouldnt affect the adult, so really we should all physically abuse those who are smaller and weaker than ourselves (thats all of u) when they do something wrong as you will learn to asscociate that action with physical pain



hittin cunts is fun

fuck shane you're so smart.

i'm going to punch the fuck out of old people now.

cunts never move out of my way.

 

[David Spade]

exactly whats an old person going to do about it

they will learn that getting in the way of young people will result in a punch

 

[ay0_x]

yeah and besides it's not like they can't call the cops or go onto the street and yell HE HIT ME and get put in a nice little cushey home unlike kids who can't do any of that.

and i bet the old person hit someone when they were more in their prime so i don't see why i shouldn't hit them all's fair in love and war.

 

[David Spade]

yeah thats the thing

if i do start going around hitting old people, i will get in trouble with the law

if i do it to children, NOT VERY HARD JUST HARD ENOUGH THAT THEY LEARN i will be fine




really the only thing stopping me hitting anyone weaker than myself is the fact that i dont want to be put up on an assault charge. children are not afforded this protection for some reason lol so i have no problem hitting them

 

[ay0_x]

everyone should have a child IMO.

throw out the punching bag and get a child.

it even cries and whimpers in pain.

all your sadistic fantasies will come to life.

 

[jennyfromdabloc]

it even cries and whimpers in pain.

That's a sign that the child is LEARNING.

Violence is an excellent way to make people good and virtuous. Parents should condition their children to violent punishment at a young age. That way they will accept a government that locks people up in violent rape dungeons for committing victimless crimes.

 

[David Spade]

criminals should be rehabilitated through physical punishment

 

[alina yousif]

By physically hurting your child, who are Already vulnerable, inexperienced and practically innocent will only cause them to do the same. You think it's okay to smack a child as a means of teaching them a lesson? Well that's completely idiotic considering the fact that children pick up things quickly. so when parent smacks a child, the child will only become even more out of control. I personally think that by speaking to them will be a more effective way of teaching them a lesson. Hence, I'm not a big fan of children anyway so I consider this post unbiased

 

[David Spade]

shut the fuck up

 

[HumanDichotomy]

Yes, while they're young.

 

[David Spade]

how

 

[ay0_x]

'cause they can't hit back.

 

[Kwayera]

everyone should have a child IMO.

throw out the punching bag and get a child.

it even cries and whimpers in pain.

all your sadistic fantasies will come to life.

Four letters:

lmao.

 

[Planck]

The argument I've not heard a reason for is why smacking is better than yelling at a child or putting them on timeout. If they won't understand you yelling at them, why will they associate you smacking them with their action? Won't they just associate smacking them with them being smacked. If they're too 'young' to understand the notions of good and bad, how does smacking enforce anything other than arbitrary violence towards the child?

Hey could one of you pro-smacking cunts address this argument? Oh that's right. You can't. Go fuck yourselves you child molesting scum.



AND FURTHER:

Just because you learned from smacking doesn't mean everyone else will, for fuck's sake everyone on the planet is different from you. I might *learn* from getting shot in the knee every time I make someone feel uncomfortable, it doesn't mean it's an acceptable outcome

 

[David Spade]

i argue that older, mature people, are more likely to make the link between bad behaviour and physical assault if they are assaulted as a punishment, so why dont we just hit cunts when they do something wrong

 

[3p1c f41lur3]

only if the children is pissing the fuck outta me then i'd probably lose my temper... but usually not the case. (unless that kid is really spoiled, then bitchslappin is fine)

 

[SylviaB]

only if the children is pissing the fuck outta me then i'd probably lose my temper... but usually not the case. (unless that kid is really spoiled, then bitchslappin is fine)

LOL.

Child abuse is okay when you're angry.

 

[murraytaylor123]

Heck yes, smack the kids and lay down the goddamn law...

IF...

...the child knows they've done something wrong, and it's a fair punishment considering.

Don't negotiate with children, they'll think they're on equal terms with the parents. They aren't. They don't make the rules, they follow the rules until they're mature enough to use their own reasoning to make their own.

My two sisters and I were smacked as punishment throughout our childhoods, and my sisters got 98+/99+ UAI's, and generally we're happy, intelligent, cultured people (Honest appraisal). I think the psychological damage argument is garbage unless you go mental and beat the crap out of kids for no good cause.

 

[David Spade]

ok bro

counterargument

if you know you have done something wrong

by your reasoning
should i not be allowed to punch you to show you that you are wrong and not on equal terms with me?

dickhead

 

[SylviaB]

My two sisters and I were smacked as punishment throughout our childhoods, and my sisters got 98+/99+ UAI's, and generally we're happy, intelligent, cultured people (Honest appraisal).

lucky all humans are identical eh