Please, Somebody Help Me!!! (1 Viewer)

death2hsc

New Member
Joined
May 28, 2004
Messages
2
Im screwed!!!
I need some stuff about Feminist critical theory and King Lear (the worst play on the plannet!), ASAP!
You scratch my back, I'll scratch yours... *wink* *wink*
Thanks guys,
please save me from an almost certain death...
Luv Manda.
 

silvermoon

caffeine fiend
Joined
Mar 14, 2004
Messages
1,834
Location
getting the blood out of my caffeine system
Gender
Female
HSC
2004
a feminist reading of lear is not what ud think it would be - IT IS NOT a reading which focuses on how the sisters are strong characters who show leadership abilities - in other words, a feminist reading does NOT set out to prove that lear shows women in a positive light. in fact, a true feminist reading is the opposite - u need 2 discuss how the treatment of the women in the play reinforces the ideology of the patriarchy. u could look at things like how womne's lust is shown as the centre of corruption, how rule under a woman leads to chaos and disruption of the natural order of things. some critics discuss cordelia's actions in the division of the kingdom scene - she will not answer lear's question properly, which goes against the duties of a daughter and thus leads to lear's disastrous decision and is thus the turning point where everything goes haywire. personally, i think thats readin a little 2 much into but meh, thats just my personal opinion. anyway, when u go over lear, just work out all the places where a shakespearian audience would have looked at the women (particularly regan and gonerill) and have seen their actions as going against the patriarchy (and producing a less than desirable result).
hope that helped at all
 

SmokedSalmon

Member
Joined
Oct 3, 2003
Messages
900
Location
for me to know and for you to find out
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2003
Reading over my old King Lear notes from last year I found the following information. I didn't write this myself btw, another boser did.

I'm not doing the feminist reading for King Lear but here's my understanding of the reading. First of all it's a partriarchal society and women are viewed in two extremes: Madonna (domesticated, nurturing, innocent) and whore (unconvetional, bold temptress). Goneril and Regan - unconventional women don't fit into the mould. In a feminist reading, (I think) you'd see how women cannot be judged so purely in terms of black and white. Even as Cordelia is quiet and innocent, she is defiant and refuses to give King Lear what he wants to hear. Goneril and Regan are presented to us like the wicked stepsisters yet if you look at the argument between Goneril and King Lear about his knights, she can be seen as reasonable and rational. She finds them to be disruptive and can't run the kingdom behaving as they are.

It's the idea of organising things within gender roles and functions. Denies stereotypes - Cordelia wilful and disobedient. I'm not sure if this is a point to bring up but it almost seems though that the roles are reversed between King Lear and Goneril. King Lear has a childish tantrum whilst Goneril is like a mother, stripping his toys away from him.

I may have gone off on a tangent but hopefully I've made sense


Cordelia's role in term of feminist interpretations can also be seen in that not only does she support patriarchal 'order', she openly upholds it in her dialogue and actions. In this interpretation, Goneril and Regan's actions are a doomed attempt to revolt against an intrinstically patriarchal system, one that is ironically inherent in the misogynistic dialogue of the text, which of course, was a common contextual belief. (The proper 'role' of women and so-on.)

Key lines in supporting this interpretation.
"You must not kneel"-Cordelia, IV, vi.
"Shame of ladies"-Cordelia, describing her sisters.
Thou hast a daughter who redeems nature from the general curse which twain have brought her to..-Gentleman, Act IV. [As can be seen, the 'threat' of matriarchal society is viewed not only as wrong, but un-natural.)
Her voice was ever soft, Gentle and low-an excellent thing in woman-Lear, Act V, Scene III. [While this is a description of Cordelia, it can be interpreted metaphorically as reinforcing stereotypical conceptions of the 'ideal' woman, which Cordelia is in terms of that context.]
Proper deformity seems not in the fiend so horrid as in womam-Albany.

The narrative and its dramatisation present a connection between sexual insubordination and anarchy, and the connection is given an explicitly misogynistic emphasis

The action of the play, the organisation of its point of view and the theatrical dynamic of its central scenes all depend upon an audience accepting an equation between 'human nature' and male power-Kathleen McLuskie, "The Patriarchal Bard".

Additionally, the upholding of patriarchy is implied in interpretations highlighting that while depicting the elimination of power structures, King Lear generally supports them [While elements of the system are criticised, notably the lack of compassion in many monarchs.. Take physic pomp..Expose thyself to feel what thy wretches feel, this reform is located within the system itself, rather than through subverting it. While the system is criticised, the results of abandoning it are depicted as catastrophic.) However, in recent adaptations, the misogyny of the original text has either been eliminated or significantly modified (An example of this is seen in Albany, with much of his misogynistic dialogue cut from the text, as otherwise, how could a contemporary audience view him as a hero? I think he's evil
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top