• Congratulations to the Class of 2024 on your results!
    Let us know how you went here
    Got a question about your uni preferences? Ask us here

Sound Cards (1 Viewer)

seremify007

Junior Member
Joined
Apr 29, 2004
Messages
10,059
Location
Sydney, Australia
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
Uni Grad
2009
AsyLum said:
Not much, you'll get a stereo sound with perhaps some simulated.

You would need something which is capable of surround sound, as far as im aware, the normal mp3 isnt capable of this, although there is a way to get it which is only recent.

http://www.hydrogenaudio.org/forums/index.php?act=ST&f=15&t=4639

Give that a read.
*reads*
I didn't even know audio CDs had rear audio channel data... thought that was only in SACDs/etc..? Not even HDCD.

But what I don't get is.. howcome when I listen to music on 5.1, the front and rear have different audio channels without even enabling any kind of audio stereo upmix? *shrugs* I was wondering if it's like that when using an integrated audio because I heard on some forums that when using onboard 5.1, the only time you hear 5.1 is when the program was designed for it; whereas with my sound blaster 5.1, it's always using all 5 speakers even in stereo output programs? *shrugs* I'm pretty sure the front/rear channels are different (i've listened very closely).
 

Collin

Active Member
Joined
Jun 17, 2003
Messages
5,084
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
N/A
From other forums, I hear the Audigy2 PCMCIA really makes a difference if you are intending to 5.1. Most people seem to be telling me that if you're just going for headphones and not doing anything intensive like music editing etc. the onboard sound is fine. So if you're not terribly rich like me and can stand not really using 5.1, I think the onboard should be fine. Well, we'll see anyway when I get this laptop tomorrow (I hope). I'd really love to avoid spending $300+ (or whatever price this thing costs right now) if I could.
 

Collin

Active Member
Joined
Jun 17, 2003
Messages
5,084
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
N/A
From other forums, I hear the Audigy2 PCMCIA really makes a difference if you are intending to 5.1. Most people seem to be telling me that if you're just going for headphones and not doing anything intensive like music editing etc. the onboard sound is fine. So if you're not terribly rich like me and can stand not really using 5.1, I think the onboard should be fine. Well, we'll see anyway when I get this laptop tomorrow (I hope). I'd really love to avoid spending $300+ (or whatever price this thing costs right now) if I could.
 

AsyLum

Premium Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2002
Messages
15,899
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
N/A
JKDDragon said:
From other forums, I hear the Audigy2 PCMCIA really makes a difference if you are intending to 5.1. Most people seem to be telling me that if you're just going for headphones and not doing anything intensive like music editing etc. the onboard sound is fine. So if you're not terribly rich like me and can stand not really using 5.1, I think the onboard should be fine. Well, we'll see anyway when I get this laptop tomorrow (I hope). I'd really love to avoid spending $300+ (or whatever price this thing costs right now) if I could.
Hey sorry, cricket was on, havent been on.

Ok, if you're primarily using headphones, the onboard is fine, since you wont be able to access the other channels unless you plan a headphone front, rear satellites as background, but seeing as you probably wont be lugging satellites around, theres no real point.


seremify007 said:
*reads*
I didn't even know audio CDs had rear audio channel data... thought that was only in SACDs/etc..? Not even HDCD.

But what I don't get is.. howcome when I listen to music on 5.1, the front and rear have different audio channels without even enabling any kind of audio stereo upmix? *shrugs* I was wondering if it's like that when using an integrated audio because I heard on some forums that when using onboard 5.1, the only time you hear 5.1 is when the program was designed for it; whereas with my sound blaster 5.1, it's always using all 5 speakers even in stereo output programs? *shrugs* I'm pretty sure the front/rear channels are different (i've listened very closely).
Hmm, not entirely sure what you're situation's about, but normally standard mp3s on 5.1 can be simulated to be 5.1, by moving part of the signal and a slight delay, you can simulate the rear as 'surround' and this can either be software or hardware activated.

If you're using CDs, then that would be reading off the stream, and the differences would most likely be due to the player. Not sure if winamp handles it automatically, but with foobar, it reads it and has the option of running a few processes to downmix it or simulate or if its 5.1 read it and play it accordingly.

Additionally it could be how the system is set up, some onboard cards, since they use the windows onboard standards, will then most likely only play 2.1 rather than the 5.1 unless specified. Cards with ASIO or with their own independent chips bypass this windows process and thus play it seamlessly.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top