The french prisoner by Janos Pilinszky (1 Viewer)

smurkie

Member
Joined
Feb 19, 2006
Messages
32
Gender
Female
HSC
2007
Hey im doing the french prisoner as part of the core text bit for my aos essay. I was wondering what the powerful message, which my teacher keeps referring to and i dont understand, of the last lines meant?

any other help is also appreciated ^^
thanks!
 

Chaosenigma

New Member
Joined
Feb 3, 2007
Messages
14
Gender
Male
HSC
2007
Well, doing the same poem, and i've been looking around for a clear message, but the only real messages in terms of the inner journey i could get was:

-that our most visceral experiences stick with us, especially when related to human desparation, and the extremes of the human psyhce (i.e what pilinszky finds inedible, the french prisoner eats ) could also relate that our experiences can be shaped by empathy and imagination, as pilinszky alludes to the french prisoners horrific ordeals by describing his physical appearance and his mindset on cattle turnip. Thus he leaves it to the audience to imagine what the prisoner has gone through to cause this.

-Guilt that follows inaction, as the protagonist mereley voyeurs at the event, and doesnt participate in helping the prisoner. (but this is kinda sketchy as Pilinszky shows not so much empathy towards the prisoner as opposed to disgust at his existance.. what a tightass XD)

Just remember, in english, what you get marks on is how well you can present an argument and back it up, not so much on what the true meaning behind it is, just your own meaning + quotes + examples to support it.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top