Union or League? Larkham or Johns? (2 Viewers)

[cappen]

At least legue sees more tries in the game. Th.

im sorry i just left at half time form the highlanders cats game and like 5 trys have been scored already, i believe thats a large amount of trys....and they are quality pieces of work....

who cares if the forwards dnt score many trys, union is about the razzle dazzle of sparkling backline moves...

and if u want forward razzle dazzle i reckon phil waugh in a ruck is pretty razzle dazzle how he can steakl the ball so often and effectively

 

[blackfriday]

the reason why union backline moves look far more spectacular is because they dont often occur and they have bigger gaps to run into because the defence rush up so quickly.

 

[Knights_chick]

Rugby Union is absolutely shit!!!!!!!!! IMO.

Somone said that League is stop start. I'm sorry, but I think you are talking about your own crap game. How bout the penalty goals that are kicked every five minutes?? That isn't stop start? And when the ball gets kicked out for the line-out? That isn't stop start? Please!!

Btw, you cannot compare Joey to Larkham. Both totally different players in different games.

 

[ChrisE]

Rugby Union is absolutely shit!!!!!!!!! IMO.

Somone said that League is stop start. I'm sorry, but I think you are talking about your own crap game. How bout the penalty goals that are kicked every five minutes?? That isn't stop start? And when the ball gets kicked out for the line-out? That isn't stop start? Please!!

Btw, you cannot compare Joey to Larkham. Both totally different players in different games.

you know nothing go away

 

[cappen]

Rugby Union is absolutely shit!!!!!!!!! IMO.

Somone said that League is stop start. I'm sorry, but I think you are talking about your own crap game. How bout the penalty goals that are kicked every five minutes?? That isn't stop start? And when the ball gets kicked out for the line-out? That isn't stop start? Please!!

Btw, you cannot compare Joey to Larkham. Both totally different players in different games.

u can talk wen the knights string sum wins together, but till then SHHHHHHHH


ps i wish joey went to union, so he coul db taught a lesson on real fuckin skill

 

[ChrisE]

ps i wish joey went to union, so he coul db taught a lesson on real fuckin skill

nah dude if johns played for the waratahs we might be where the knights are, dead last.

 

[RiCe_GrOwEr]

Where is Larkham anyways? Joey Johns has pretty much scored most the points for the Knights. He is the only player playing half decent for the Knights.

Nice choke by the Knights.

 

[cappen]

Where is Larkham anyways? Joey Johns has pretty much scored most the points for the Knights. He is the only player playing half decent for the Knights.

Nice choke by the Knights.

larkam is injured atm....well who gives a shit bout joey now, hes done finished, if he scores most of the knights points, then they wont b scoring many more this season thats for sure....

 

[angelduck]

danny boderus is wayyyy good 4 knights as well

 

[Knights_chick]

This thread has nothing to do with the Knights. If it was will be talking in the NRL thread.
So, in my opinion Union is crap and League is a way better game.

 

[Espo15]

there's no point arguing here. people have different opinions, and they will probably not change these opinions because someone on the intarweb told them to.

personally i enjoy watching/playing union far more than league, however there have been some awesome tries in league recently.

 

[blackfriday]

union is cool if you're a back and have the speed to slice through gaps or you just have a kicking fetish.

 

[ChrisE]

union is supercool if you are a forward sick of the up and down back and fowrard boredom of being a league forward and actually want to get in there and have a dig, contest scrums and be involved at nearly every play.

 

[tammer]

i enjoy both union and league but i do think union is a better game.

and as far as larkham vs. johns goes, i can't stand andrew johns so i've have to go with larkham for sure.

 

[chookie_06]

i love both union and league. love larkham but cant stand johns... who do u reckon got my vote

 

[AsyLum]

As a forward i think going from league > union would be quite difficult particularly with all the rules.

As a back, i think it'd be quite easy as the same concepts are in league, just with the set defensive line it is more difficult to do things like that, a good scrum set play though is awesome.

We can outline particular stars who succeeded and who didnt, it all comes down to the person i think.

I find a bust through the ruck by a slight of hand from a five-eight to a bursting winger/fullback much more appealing. (ala lockyer > billy slater) Its exciting to see the brand of league being played nowdays, especially by the younger teams.

Seeing the first hit - up during the state of origin and other big hits are what appeals to me, it may be dumb, but seeing webcke collide with other big forwards and for him to do it over and over (shame he retired from rep) was one of the reasons i enjoyed brisbane games.

 

[libertine]

larkham has a better passing and running game than johns. How often have we seen larkham just split defences with his runs. Larkham's weakness has always been his kickign and this is where johns is superior. I think Larkham would be ridiculously good in league. Im judging this on the fact that its a lot easier for a Union Back to go to League than it is the other way around.

Union pisses all over League. Games are more intriguing and tactical and basically BETTER. Union players are stronger, faster and smarter. And we all know which game is better at the internaitonal level.

However,

Football >Union> AFL> League

 

[cappen]

Football >Union> AFL> League

i disagree
Football > Union >AFL = League

 

[blackfriday]

afl must be the singlest most boring sport to watch, but playing it isnt so bad though.

 

[RiCe_GrOwEr]

Larkhams out for another week.