Advice on whether to drop subjects? (2 Viewers)

Espy25

New Member
Joined
Feb 12, 2012
Messages
12
Gender
Male
HSC
2012
Hello, new member, been a lurker for a while but recently signed up and this is my first time posting.

Firstly I'd like to state that I'm doing 12 units at my school (rank: around 50th) and they are as follows:

4 Unit Mathematics Extension 2
2 Unit English Advanced
2 Unit Physics
2 Unit Economics
2 Unit Legal Studies

As of now, I'm contemplating on whether to drop Extension 2 Maths or Physics as they are my weakest subjects and also require the most effort to learn in my opinion. My teachers have told us to figure out what to drop after we've done our half yearlies, to reassure ourselves that it's for the best. I haven't had an Ext 2 Test due to my school's weird schedule but I've done Physics and am doing average if not slightly below. If I drop physics I'd have 10 units and if I drop Ext 2 Maths i'd have 11 units. I was thinking 11 is safer than 10 but dropping Physics means that I don't have to split my focus on a COMPLETELY different subject such as Physics. However I'd have 10 units and I am told it isn't safe. Dropping Ext 2 on the other hand means I'll have 11 units but I'm not sure if I can do well in Physics.

However there is an option of dropping NONE and just spending more effort and time to ensure a higher ATAR. I am aiming for 95+ or around.

Just an extra question, between Ext 2 Maths and Physics, which would require more effort/give bigger workload?

Thank you.
 

someth1ng

Retired Nov '14
Joined
Sep 18, 2010
Messages
5,558
Location
Adelaide, Australia
Gender
Male
HSC
2012
Uni Grad
2021
I would drop Physics. Maths Extension 2 has immensely high scaling so "doing bad" could be as good as getting a 90 in another subject. Also, if you drop Maths Extension 2, Physics will definitely count as a "good" but not incredible scaling subject so not doing good in it will most likely pull you down.
 

Bored_of_HSC

Active Member
Joined
Jul 9, 2011
Messages
1,498
Gender
Female
HSC
2012
Welcome to BOS.

How are you going in your other subs? Because if you are quite confident about these then you could just drop without too many worries.

As for your last question, for most people ex2 maths requires more effort. The leap from 3u to 4u is really big (as compared with the increase from 2u to 3u).

But yeah i'd agree with some1thing. If you don't mind pulling off the hard yards for 4u then it can be VERY rewarding. (85 in 4u is basically the same as 95 in 2u).
 

SunnyScience

Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2011
Messages
706
Gender
Male
HSC
2012
From the way you've constructed your post, i am going to go with drop physics, as it comes across to me as that's what you really want - but wait till after the half-yearlies.

Edit:
Seeing as you're doing extn 2 anyway, your teachers and/or yourself must have had a reason to let you do it/want to do it
 

Dylanamali

Active Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2009
Messages
1,248
Gender
Male
HSC
2011
if aiming for 95+, i'd drop physics..
if aiming for 99+, i'd drop mx2..

reason being.. mx2 prevented me from attaining 99+, because I was quite a dodgy maths student. In saying that, i only achieved probably 50% raw in the hsc exam and that still aligned to 80 hsc mark and that 80 hsc mark will still be equivalent to an atar of 95+. IMO, it's preety easy to attain 50% raw in mx2 in comparison to a 80-85% raw in physics to get a similar mark.
In the end, if I was to do 2u maths, I'd most likely finish with an allrounders and a 99+ atar. food for thought.
 

Aceitachi

Member
Joined
Feb 12, 2012
Messages
47
Location
Heaven
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2013
If your good at maths stick with everything you have and i suggest you drop legal studies.
 

study-freak

Bored of
Joined
Feb 8, 2008
Messages
1,133
Gender
Male
HSC
2009
I'd say wait till you do your 1st MX2 assessment and get your results/compare it to Physics keeping in mind the aligning/scaling.

It is generally agreed that MX2 requires heavier workload than Physics but it depends on your Maths vs Physics abilities.

Drop either one of those if you feel that you can quite surely not do as well in one subject as all other subjects, but if similar, try asking yourself which one you find more tedious and time consuming. If very very similar in the end, it shouldn't matter which one you drop, right? but if that case comes, I'll just say that it's easier to 'bomb' the exam in MX2 than in Physics (generally).
 

Cl324

Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2011
Messages
264
Gender
Male
HSC
N/A
if aiming for 95+, i'd drop physics..
if aiming for 99+, i'd drop mx2..

reason being.. mx2 prevented me from attaining 99+, because I was quite a dodgy maths student. In saying that, i only achieved probably 50% raw in the hsc exam and that still aligned to 80 hsc mark and that 80 hsc mark will still be equivalent to an atar of 95+. IMO, it's preety easy to attain 50% raw in mx2 in comparison to a 80-85% raw in physics to get a similar mark.
In the end, if I was to do 2u maths, I'd most likely finish with an allrounders and a 99+ atar. food for thought.

For mark of 80, you achieved just above the 25th percentile of the state. You probably got less than 50% raw.
For the same scaled mark in 2u, you'd have to achieve within the 85th percentile.
According to your 3u mark, you're pretty decent at maths and youd be the rare case of someone who wouldve performed better with 2u.
Your marks are great anyway, im sure it wouldnt have had that much impact on your atar!
However generally the rule is if you have a chance to study 4u, do it
Scaling is phenomenal and if you are equally weak at mx2 and physics, drop physics
Only keep phyysics if you are SIGNIFICANTLY weaker at mx2
 

someth1ng

Retired Nov '14
Joined
Sep 18, 2010
Messages
5,558
Location
Adelaide, Australia
Gender
Male
HSC
2012
Uni Grad
2021
If you got 80 exam mark - your raw must be lower than 50%.

I think Shadowdude for 83 with 59/120 so an 80 is probably low-40s% raw mark.
 

Dylanamali

Active Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2009
Messages
1,248
Gender
Male
HSC
2011
yeah, preety bad i think around 50-55/120 probs.. preety bad flunk hahaha, in comparison to my other marks :O
 

ibbybiby

Member
Joined
Jun 1, 2010
Messages
36
Gender
Female
HSC
2012
As of now, I'm contemplating on whether to drop Extension 2 Maths or Physics as they are my weakest subjects and also require the most effort to learn in my opinion. My teachers have told us to figure out what to drop after we've done our half yearlies, to reassure ourselves that it's for the best. I haven't had an Ext 2 Test due to my school's weird schedule but I've done Physics and am doing average if not slightly below. If I drop physics I'd have 10 units and if I drop Ext 2 Maths i'd have 11 units. I was thinking 11 is safer than 10 but dropping Physics means that I don't have to split my focus on a COMPLETELY different subject such as Physics. However I'd have 10 units and I am told it isn't safe. Dropping Ext 2 on the other hand means I'll have 11 units but I'm not sure if I can do well in Physics.

However there is an option of dropping NONE and just spending more effort and time to ensure a higher ATAR. I am aiming for 95+ or around.

Just an extra question, between Ext 2 Maths and Physics, which would require more effort/give bigger workload?

Thank you.
I'm in pretty much the same situation except I do Chemistry instead of Legal Studies. I'm juggling between MX2 and every other 2u subjects but English (so sad I can't drop it D: ) I've been told to wait till half-yearlies, but I don't know if I want to, it would feel so good to have some more free periods. It's really hard to decide what to drop because my marks are all about the same for everything >80%.
 
Joined
Jul 22, 2009
Messages
107
Location
Sydney
Gender
Male
HSC
2011
Uni Grad
2017
This is what I suggest:

Keep all your subjects for as long as possible till after the half yearlies. From you half yearly examination results, decide on what to drop. I was a science/maths sort of guy so if I was in your position I would drop legal studies. However, if you are good at humanities, physics has a significant humanities/history section which you can do well in. If you want to well in MX2, you will have to put a lot of effort in.

For those of you in year 11 atm, I would advise you to start year 12 with 14 units and then drop down subjects later on. The logic behind this is that the early strain of having 14 units is a lot less compared to the flexibility you will have later on in your more stressful periods (ie trials).
 

alstah

Member
Joined
Mar 28, 2009
Messages
510
Location
Sydney
Gender
Male
HSC
2011
Uni Grad
2016
If you're getting great grades in Legal Studies and you enjoy it, then keep it! Drop the subject you don't like the most, its as simple as that...lol
 

Bobbo1

Member
Joined
Apr 19, 2011
Messages
971
Gender
Male
HSC
2010
Don't drop anything atleast until after the half yearlies...
 

zoelea

New Member
Joined
Feb 15, 2012
Messages
4
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
N/A
Your teachers are giving you the right advice, its best to decide after half yearlies when you get a better idea of your performance. However, i personally believe your better off sticking to the subjects you'll do better in, rather than worrying about scaling, which changes from year to year as it dependent on how hard the test for that year was, not the particular subject, for example if everybody in the state smashes physics, it'll get scaled down because the exam was to easy compared to another subject were everybody struggled. You cant predict scaling, so it shouldnt be a factor when choosing subjects.
 

Dylanamali

Active Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2009
Messages
1,248
Gender
Male
HSC
2011
Your teachers are giving you the right advice, its best to decide after half yearlies when you get a better idea of your performance. However, i personally believe your better off sticking to the subjects you'll do better in, rather than worrying about scaling, which changes from year to year as it dependent on how hard the test for that year was, not the particular subject, for example if everybody in the state smashes physics, it'll get scaled down because the exam was to easy compared to another subject were everybody struggled. You cant predict scaling, so it shouldnt be a factor when choosing subjects.
it definitely should be a factor when choosing subjects..
scaling may change from year to year, but if you look at the past 5 or so years it's quite clear that chem, phys, mx1 and mx2 ALIGN so much better than most other subjects.. I'm quite sure that these will always be the best aligning and scaling subjects.. so if your good at sci and maths choose 4u and chem+bio.
 

someth1ng

Retired Nov '14
Joined
Sep 18, 2010
Messages
5,558
Location
Adelaide, Australia
Gender
Male
HSC
2012
Uni Grad
2021
if everybody in the state smashes physics, it'll get scaled down because the exam was to easy compared to another subject were everybody struggled. You cant predict scaling, so it shouldnt be a factor when choosing subjects.
This isn't true. If everyone did well (easy test), then the subject would align lower. If everyone met criteria for Band 6, everyone would get Band 6.

Scaling is done by UAC and is based upon how the cohort performs in a subject compared to another subject (usually English) to make a comparison between difficulty of the exam/subject and how good the candidature is.

Take last year's Physics exam as an example. Last year's exam was considered very easy but the scaling was almost identical to other years. Go figure.
 

Dylanamali

Active Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2009
Messages
1,248
Gender
Male
HSC
2011
This isn't true. If everyone did well (easy test), then the subject would align lower. If everyone met criteria for Band 6, everyone would get Band 6.

Scaling is done by UAC and is based upon how the cohort performs in a subject compared to another subject (usually English) to make a comparison between difficulty of the exam/subject and how good the candidature is.

Take last year's Physics exam as an example. Last year's exam was considered very easy but the scaling was almost identical to other years. Go figure.
+1, very good post, repped. edit: would rep but i've repped you too many times =/

yeah scaling was the same.. however i think the exam aligned less favourably then previous years.
 
Last edited:

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 2)

Top