Is getting an MX 5 a good idea for first car. (1 Viewer)

astroman

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 12, 2014
Messages
7,069
Location
Las Vegas
Gender
Male
HSC
2015
it's a great little car, ticks all the boxes, fun to drive, easy to handle, manual, convertible, small, nice array of mods, rwd, cheap. Go for it
 

Speed6

Retired '16
Joined
Jul 31, 2014
Messages
2,949
Gender
Male
HSC
N/A
it's a great little car, ticks all the boxes, fun to drive, easy to handle, manual, convertible, small, nice array of mods, rwd, cheap. Go for it
Astroman just stole the words right out of my mouth xD
 

Chronost

Ex CAG auditor - current CAG deal-maker
Joined
Dec 9, 2011
Messages
1,159
Location
where people need auditing
Gender
Female
HSC
2013
Not as a first car, I would go something for more economical and something which would have you pay less insurance each year, in addition take to mind safety into the car, really just get a old Honda civic and learn to drive a sedan before you go into a convertible/coupe. How do you even have money for an MX 5?
 

turntaker

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 29, 2013
Messages
3,908
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2015
Not as a first car, I would go something for more economical and something which would have you pay less insurance each year, in addition take to mind safety into the car, really just get a old Honda civic and learn to drive a sedan before you go into a convertible/coupe. How do you even have money for an MX 5?
you can get one for 4000-7000
I am talking about the first gen 1989-1998.
Also they are economical since its a 1.6 litre engine. I dont think the insurance is that much higher. If it was a coupe it would be a lot

Also honda civics are pretty expensive concidering their age and size.
Parts are really expensive on hondas.
 
Last edited:

Chronost

Ex CAG auditor - current CAG deal-maker
Joined
Dec 9, 2011
Messages
1,159
Location
where people need auditing
Gender
Female
HSC
2013
you can get one for 4000-7000
I am talking about the first gen 1989-1998.
Also they are economical since its a 1.6 litre engine. I dont think the insurance is that much higher. If it was a coupe it would be a lot

Also honda civics are pretty expensive concidering their age and size.
Parts are really expensive on hondas.
Lol 4000-7000, gl with your 250k KMs and rust which is an apparent problem with old mx-5s
First gen ones are the ones that you see old people drive, it just doesn't fit the uni student mold (it really doesn't look that good - the first gen ones)
1997-98 onwards its a 1.8L engine.

Parts aren't much cheaper for mazada either, especially old MX-5 parts - not to mention old MX-5s have a history of clutch problems

not really, 8k gets you a nice 2005-2007 model with 100k kms
trust me Honda parts are well priced, where did you even hear that Honda parts are more expensive? Toyota and Honda are on par with each other, if anything Mazada parts are the bit more expensive ones.
 

turntaker

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 29, 2013
Messages
3,908
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2015
Lol 4000-7000, gl with your 250k KMs and rust which is an apparent problem with old mx-5s
First gen ones are the ones that you see old people drive, it just doesn't fit the uni student mold (it really doesn't look that good - the first gen ones)
1997-98 onwards its a 1.8L engine.

Parts aren't much cheaper for mazada either, especially old MX-5 parts - not to mention old MX-5s have a history of clutch problems

not really, 8k gets you a nice 2005-2007 model with 100k kms
trust me Honda parts are well priced, where did you even hear that Honda parts are more expensive? Toyota and Honda are on par with each other, if anything Mazada parts are the bit more expensive ones.
A well looked after MX5 will go for 350,000kms.

Also I have looked at the market and you can get some for a pretty low milage.

I think the car looks pretty cool actually. I don't wanna fit into the mould.

Don't really care if old people drive it. Its a cool little car.

The clutch can also be replaced by a cheap clutch kit
 

Drifting95

Should i change my DP?
Joined
Mar 14, 2012
Messages
3,160
Location
Point Piper
Gender
Male
HSC
2013
it's a great little car, ticks all the boxes, fun to drive, easy to handle, manual, convertible, small, nice array of mods, rwd, cheap. Go for it
Have you driven one or just heard from the internet? It might be fun to drive for that once in a while cruise around royal nasho but for daily driving i don't think so. They are a weekend type car and not really something you'd want to deal with everyday.

My mate has one and it's such a nugget that his gf's yaris is quicker. Forget trying to merge lanes or overtake in normal conditions but they're gutless and have no torque.

Not trying to be overly negative but just consider how you will feel driving it everyday. My mate made that mistake and is selling his now because it's just too uncomfortable. If you can handle the negatives and will use it how it's meant to be driven (nasho runs etc) then go for it but for a daily cruiser there are better options.

Some common faults
-leaky roof (you'll love that wet seat surprise in the morning when you drive to the train station).
-rust
-buggered electric windows
-worn out rubber seals causing leaks everywhere (e.g the boot)
 

Drifting95

Should i change my DP?
Joined
Mar 14, 2012
Messages
3,160
Location
Point Piper
Gender
Male
HSC
2013
you can get one for 4000-7000
I am talking about the first gen 1989-1998.
Also they are economical since its a 1.6 litre engine. I dont think the insurance is that much higher. If it was a coupe it would be a lot

Also honda civics are pretty expensive concidering their age and size.
Parts are really expensive on hondas.
Yeah, insurance and fuel economy isn't really an issue.

Civic parts are cheap but you need to use the genuine oil which is a bit more expensive than normal. The more expensive honda parts are found on the honda euro and newer models, not really something that would be an issue for the cars in the price range you're looking at. Civics aren't expensive, owners just put inflated prices on gumtree/carsales (i paid $1300 for a 1 owner ek with 95 000km on it).
 

turntaker

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 29, 2013
Messages
3,908
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2015
Have you driven one or just heard from the internet? It might be fun to drive for that once in a while cruise around royal nasho but for daily driving i don't think so. They are a weekend type car and not really something you'd want to deal with everyday.

My mate has one and it's such a nugget that his gf's yaris is quicker. Forget trying to merge lanes or overtake in normal conditions but they're gutless and have no torque.

Not trying to be overly negative but just consider how you will feel driving it everyday. My mate made that mistake and is selling his now because it's just too uncomfortable. If you can handle the negatives and will use it how it's meant to be driven (nasho runs etc) then go for it but for a daily cruiser there are better options.

Some common faults
-leaky roof (you'll love that wet seat surprise in the morning when you drive to the train station).
-rust
-buggered electric windows
-worn out rubber seals causing leaks everywhere (e.g the boot)
You could be right about driving it everyday. But I will probably never own a 2 seat roadster when I'm older because of how unpractical it is.
Now its not that big of a deal for me.

I also want something that's fun and somewhat uncommon.
So I think the mx5 fits my criteria
 

OzKo

Retired
Joined
Jul 17, 2007
Messages
9,892
Gender
Male
HSC
2009
Uni Grad
2013
Lol 4000-7000, gl with your 250k KMs and rust which is an apparent problem with old mx-5s
First gen ones are the ones that you see old people drive, it just doesn't fit the uni student mold (it really doesn't look that good - the first gen ones)
1997-98 onwards its a 1.8L engine.

Parts aren't much cheaper for mazada either, especially old MX-5 parts - not to mention old MX-5s have a history of clutch problems

not really, 8k gets you a nice 2005-2007 model with 100k kms
trust me Honda parts are well priced, where did you even hear that Honda parts are more expensive? Toyota and Honda are on par with each other, if anything Mazada parts are the bit more expensive ones.
Are you serious?

I was looking at 2005-09 models a few months ago and the cheapest I could find was $18k.
 

anomalousdecay

Premium Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2013
Messages
5,766
Gender
Male
HSC
2013
Have you driven one or just heard from the internet? It might be fun to drive for that once in a while cruise around royal nasho but for daily driving i don't think so. They are a weekend type car and not really something you'd want to deal with everyday.

My mate has one and it's such a nugget that his gf's yaris is quicker. Forget trying to merge lanes or overtake in normal conditions but they're gutless and have no torque.

Not trying to be overly negative but just consider how you will feel driving it everyday. My mate made that mistake and is selling his now because it's just too uncomfortable. If you can handle the negatives and will use it how it's meant to be driven (nasho runs etc) then go for it but for a daily cruiser there are better options.

Some common faults
-leaky roof (you'll love that wet seat surprise in the morning when you drive to the train station).
-rust
-buggered electric windows
-worn out rubber seals causing leaks everywhere (e.g the boot)
It's definitely not a daily driver.

A more comfortable daily driver would be a Mazda 3 or Corolla or Impreza, etc.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top