Can I see pictures?
Are we talking "sort of pointy" or "actually pointy"?
If the former, probably ok, particularly if Carson from Queer Guy says it's ok.
If the latter, guys shouldn't be wearing them. As someone said earlier, they're uber metro (NOT normal metro). There's a fine line in regards to gender fashion these days... us girls can wear YOUR clothes, but you can't wear OURS (this includes pointy-toed shoes. They are firmly entrenched within the female realm, ta). Straight guys and pointy toed shoes just don't seem to mix... I mean, we expect straight guys to have a certain amount of "masculinity" about them. A symbol of femininity - such as pointy-toed shoes - just breaks this image. It's uncomfortable because it just doesn't seem right...