still waiting
Member
i agree u have to read them first i think to fully enjoy their stories.....The_highwayman said:
-
Finished your HSC? Check out our University Discussion, Non-School forums or help out next year's HSC students! -
YOU can help the next generation of students in the community! Share your trial papers and notes on our Notes & Resources page
HARRY POTTER & THE HBP - what did you think? (SPOILERS!) (5 Viewers)
- Thread starter bubz :D
- Start date
Bunny04
VIVE LA FRANCE
- Joined
- Oct 18, 2004
- Messages
- 995
- Gender
- Female
- HSC
- 2004
Yeah, i really love Prisoner of Azkaban, but i have to say Half Blood Prince is one of my favourites ^_^
transcendent
Active Member
Nah I like how the movies gave a representation of the characters physically. My main tiff is that they didn't do it scene by scene exactly as the book which is how I'd of prefered it.The_highwayman said:
Mini
relax
someone questioned fortescue the icecream dude being dragged off before... i know its a minor plot detail but one of the old Headmasters was called Fortescue - perhaps this was his son/grandson or something and thus in league with Dumbledore. It would explain why he was so helpful and kind to harry in book 3.
Other than that, I loved book 6 - snape is INNOCENT, dammit, for all the reasons posted by others - and i do believe she did go a little overboard with the ships.
Other than that, I loved book 6 - snape is INNOCENT, dammit, for all the reasons posted by others - and i do believe she did go a little overboard with the ships.
yeah I know, they screwed the first book, I hated how they cut out all the challenges! and emma did a very bad job of that scene where she leaves harry to do his thang.....transcendent said:
interestingly jk thought it was exactly how she imagined it, the sets I mean, she said it was like walking into her own head...
scoby_2000
Member
cherryblossom said:
....would you say "wow that was shit....nothing like i expected...chris columbus...wat a fucken idiot"
hehe....actuallly.....i probably would
simmic
red-headed tensai
im pretty sure voldemort would know if harry was a horcrux. He would definately be able to feel it.
Perhaps horcruxes could be reversed and that was what voldemort did with harry's blood in OoTP, he took back a part of his soul thus making his form more stronger than before?
Perhaps horcruxes could be reversed and that was what voldemort did with harry's blood in OoTP, he took back a part of his soul thus making his form more stronger than before?
haha...fortunately i never see rupert grint as ron. but when i visualise harry potter scenes, daniel radcliffe is always harry. the movies do a fairly good job, but they just don't have the life and humour that the books do (and i do not count ron-comic-relief as humour...i love ron very much and wish he wasn't maligned in the movies).Argonaut said:
transcendent
Active Member
But Ronald's always been a bit of a prat. 
He really doesn't deserve Hermoine in both the film and the book.
He really doesn't deserve Hermoine in both the film and the book.
scoby_2000
Member
simmic said:
but they do feel each other!!! thats the fucking thing!
scoby_2000
Member
i imagine myself as harry potter
The_highwayman
Banned
- Joined
- Oct 27, 2004
- Messages
- 4,317
- Gender
- Male
- HSC
- 2005
i imagine myself as dumbledore, but now i'm dead...or at least so it seems. i'm not quite sure of my state of liveliness at the moment.
simmic
red-headed tensai
erh... i think i was trying to quote someone... but forgot... but im saying is that voldemort would definately know if harry carries part of his soul so he wouldnt be trying to kill off a part of himselve without knowing it.scoby_2000 said:
jason_granger
......jd
ginny came across as a bit of a slut i reckon....i cant believe harry actually likes her...
oh harry what has become of you?
oh harry what has become of you?
The_highwayman
Banned
- Joined
- Oct 27, 2004
- Messages
- 4,317
- Gender
- Male
- HSC
- 2005
yeah. he was going on about the beast or something roaring inside him each time she laughed or smiled in his direction. it was obvious. she's liked him since CoS
nooo!!!! ginny's not a slut. seriously, think about it - she dates a grand total of three guys (michael corner, dean and harry) within almost three years. for a fifteen year old girl (who is popular, lively, good at sports and so pretty that even slytherins and a death eater in combat say so) that's pretty good i reckon.jason_granger said:
and harry and ginny has been brewing for a while. even in ootp - she was the only person who could deal with harry-in-a-temper, while other people whimpered - and she was the one who comforted him in the library about sirius. of course harry would go for a girl who was gorgeous and loads of fun, who could understand him and comfort him and who liked him!
mmm - yeah...been an H/G fan for ages.
and to the person who thought ronald didn't deserve hermione - i must say, in HBP hermione annoyed me so much i couldn't see what ron saw in her!! ron might be a bit more immature and have an inferiority complex, but he's fiercely loyal, funny, dependable and lovely. if he's not as brainy as her, then (in fleur's words) hermione has brains enough for two!!