• Congratulations to the Class of 2024 on your results!
    Let us know how you went here
    Got a question about your uni preferences? Ask us here

posibility? UWS: B design (visual comm)- UTS: B design (visual comm) O_o (1 Viewer)

Status
Not open for further replies.

juni

juni
Joined
Jan 6, 2005
Messages
66
Location
Sydney
Gender
Female
HSC
2003
msh said:
well everyone has a possiblity of getting a transfer, except that its EXTREMELY competitive.
You have the ones coming in with the high UAIs from high school and then many others from private schools etc
Also your peers at UWS all trying it out when there are only 10~15 non current school leaver positions :mad1:

Also, ignore Netstar's comment on not needing a DEGREE to get into Design.
Honestly, I'm sorry but your comments are ignorant and rather unwarranted with very little factual evidences.

I have some strong backing for my point and here it goes.

This is directly from Design Institute of Australia. (DIA)

What do employers expect?
Some employers will be satisfied with the training offered by the shorter courses but employers who apply more formal assessment of applicants prior to hiring are likely to place importance on the apparently more substantial degree qualification.

There are large numbers of graduates in all disciplines so an employer who advertises a job position will generally receive a large number of applications. Many employers, and particularly those in design consultancies, are likely to use level and duration of design education as one of the ways to reduce the list of applicants down to a manageable short list to interview. So if design is your chosen career, striving to get into and complete a degree is the surest way to start.

In keeping with professional training currently available the DIA recommends four years of tertiary design training to degree level.

http://www.dia.org.au/content.cfm?id=112

Not to mention, you don't even qualify to the professional designer membership of Australia given out by DIA with a tafe diploma.

If DIA (The professional body for designers in Australia) is strongly recommending a 4 yrs DEGREE in Design, who is Netstar or anybody for that matter to suggest 'you don't need a degree from uni to get into design.'

So yes... It would be wise to strive to the highest level of design to be a sucessful designer in the future and survive in this competitive industry.
This is absolutely correct. Most senior/head design positions that are advertised these days specifically asks 'minimum of 4 yrs in a design degree'

So obviously, if you aspire to the highest level of design, striving to get into a reputable uni degree is a good start to it, just like what the DIA is recommending :)
 
Last edited:

groovejet

Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2007
Messages
70
Gender
Male
HSC
N/A
Hey Natstar, no disrespect but I think the issue is the reality of design now. I however do not understand Juni, how you have said, "Most senior/head design positions that are advertised these days specifically asks 'minimum of 4 yrs in a design degree" The DIA recommends that individuals who are serious should undertake a 4 year tertiary degree but it does mean everyone has to go this route. Agencies or studios do not state that you have to have a degree but they state that they require certain personal attributes like any other profession and of course, 2 or more years in general of real industry experience. This also depends on what position you are applying and if you intend to apply as a junior designer, you would need a good portfolio or instead, at least a year of industry experience.

I want to take the two perceptives in saying that on one hand, you can do a university degree to study design but on the other, you don't have to to become successful and evidently, there are many who have been extremely successful without one. The DIA recommends a 4 year degree because within a 4 year time period, it's a significant amount of tme in which you can take on projects. The first 2 years is essentially to learn and establish your work and improve your skills and work. The last two is where you take on projects where it is largely self-intiated. Look at it this way, if it was 3 years it would be too short, 5 years and it feels too long. Why are the medical degrees take more that 5 years? For the same reasons. The degree is not 4 years for the sake of being 4 years. The university has obviously had consultation with the Faculty, Dean and the Academic Board who sets out the rules and the admissions process. Instead of arguing how long the degree should be why doesn't the university or even the DIA consider all students who want to consider design as a profession to first take a foundation design course. If students can't apply themselves or are not interested in design from that point and if they don't achieve good results, they should have consultation to see if this is what they really want. Successful completion of a foundation course would mean moving to the actual start of the bachelor degree.

One of things I don't like is how the DIA can define all this kind of information which seems to be so advanced for first and second year students. They state all this kind of information yet they don't really help us directly by offering help or assistance or having conferences or special talks. The only advice I think which is real and straight forward is from your tutors and lecturers.
 
Last edited:

vick1_zha0

New Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2005
Messages
7
Location
Unknown
Gender
Female
HSC
2006
hey s1mplykat

just wondering... how did u travel to penrith on academic advisory day?
did u have to go city first to catch the train?
and one more question how was the academic advisory day? was it important?
 

groovejet

Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2007
Messages
70
Gender
Male
HSC
N/A
natstar said:
Yeah I know what your talking about, but I dont people saying that my comments are ignorant and unwarranted when I only made a suggestion. How am I to know how serious she is about what she wants to do. As I mentioned, when I wanted to do this I spoke to my aunty and uncle who are both visual arts teachers and studied at private colleges in the UK rather than universities, both specialised in photography before going into teaching, as well as a family friend who has done work for the publication Gormeat Traveller, and whom reccomended me to study at a private college as he felt universities are not practical enough.
I only suggested this becuase its just another option she could have taken.
I appreciate what you have said, I can't speak for the other person though.
I did not go to that advisory day, missed the very first lecture but it didn't matter. Your first class will be in the BB building and in that first class, you introduce yourself etc etc and get comfortable.
 

juni

juni
Joined
Jan 6, 2005
Messages
66
Location
Sydney
Gender
Female
HSC
2003
groovejet said:
Hey Natstar, no disrespect but I think the issue is the reality of design now. I however do not understand Juni, how you have said, "Most senior/head design positions that are advertised these days specifically asks 'minimum of 4 yrs in a design degree" The DIA recommends that individuals who are serious should undertake a 4 year tertiary degree but it does mean everyone has to go this route. Agencies or studios do not state that you have to have a degree but they state that they require certain personal attributes like any other profession and of course, 2 or more years in general of real industry experience. This also depends on what position you are applying and if you intend to apply as a junior designer, you would need a good portfolio or instead, at least a year of industry experience.

I want to take the two perceptives in saying that on one hand, you can do a university degree to study design but on the other, you don't have to to become successful and evidently, there are many who have been extremely successful without one. The DIA recommends a 4 year degree because within a 4 year time period, it's a significant amount of tme in which you can take on projects. The first 2 years is essentially to learn and establish your work and improve your skills and work. The last two is where you take on projects where it is largely self-intiated. Look at it this way, if it was 3 years it would be too short, 5 years and it feels too long. Why are the medical degrees take more that 5 years? For the same reasons. The degree is not 4 years for the sake of being 4 years. The university has obviously had consultation with the Faculty, Dean and the Academic Board who sets out the rules and the admissions process. Instead of arguing how long the degree should be why doesn't the university or even the DIA consider all students who want to consider design as a profession to first take a foundation design course. If students can't apply themselves or are not interested in design from that point and if they don't achieve good results, they should have consultation to see if this is what they really want. Successful completion of a foundation course would mean moving to the actual start of the bachelor degree.

One of things I don't like is how the DIA can define all this kind of information which seems to be so advanced for first and second year students. They state all this kind of information yet they don't really help us directly by offering help or assistance or having conferences or special talks. The only advice I think which is real and straight forward is from your tutors and lecturers.
Sorry I don't quiet get what you are suggesting here. It seems contradictory in the sense you disagree with Netstar, suggesting it is the 'reality of design' industry that they want degreed grads whilst you don't quiet get why i said 'Most senior/head design positions that are advertised these days specifically asks 'minimum of 4 yrs in a design degree.'
I believe we both have the same belief rather than opposing opinions lol; (Isn't that why you are at UWS doing a 4 years degree in design?)

Just do a quick search for Design related positions at a senior level and you wil find more that says 4 yrs degree and 5 or more yrs of experience etc :)

Obviously it seems logical what DIA has suggested. Would you as an employer choose someone with 4 yrs of study/experience or 2yrs of study/experience? I find it interesting that some employers according to DIA sorts out their potential candiates based on yrs of study and filters out the ones with less experience.
Like what DIA said, if you are serious about design as a career they recommend you to go get a degree, it's not mandatary but you would aspire to if you are serious about getting far. :) If this wasn't true, how do you justify the ridiculously high cut-offs for design at UTS? Or the number of people trying to get into it as well. Also, like what DIA said, most design degrees these days are 4 yrs in length such as the UTS, UNSW and UWS one.

Who wouldn't dream of becoming a CREATIVE DIRECTOR? :D
 
Last edited:

msh

Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2007
Messages
133
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2004
natstar said:
Um where did I say that you dont need a degree to get into design??? I mearly only suggested that she perhaps apply to a private college that specialises in the field (that does not require a UAI) instead of stuffing around with uni transfers that are not guaranteed. In addition, before you call my comments ignorant and unwarranted, maybe you should actually look at the fact that private providers like KvB do have bachelor degrees http://www.kvb.edu.au/course_overview.html.
Even if she wants to get a degree form a university, she can always transfer from a private college to a university.

Please, dont think I havent done my research. As I said, I was very interested in getting into this field when I was doing the HSC.
I don't know what is there to argue about this honestly.
There are other options besides universities but why would any major multi national agencies pick a 2yr private school grad over those who studied hard to get the UAI and is also creative/talented? (The reality is outlined by DIA as well, the fact that they sort out potential employers by drawing out the ones without a degree)

I appreciate you have an opinion on this issue but this is my researched findings supported by a governing body that represents DESIGNERS in AUSTRALIA by the Design Institute of Australia.

We are talking about 'highest level' of design practice like what DIA is suggesting. People that will eventually become senior and head of their departments and possible creative directors at an international level, not a graphic technician at Gourmet traveller. That obviously can be achieved just with the techinical learning but design is a business profession and study of the theory and being able to think at an intellectual level will undeniably outshine those that are only capable of the 'technical.'

I'll tell you the type of people you are faced in terms of competition. People who came FIRST in the state for Visual Arts, people that received a uai of 90 and over and some even with 100 (yes, 100). Most people with a band 6 result in Visual arts, D&T, Textiles and design, English extensions etc along with numerous awards/competition winners/exhibitors and those that got picked in selective extension art courses/exhibitions.

This is my findings.
 
Last edited:

s1mplykat

Member
Joined
Sep 10, 2005
Messages
149
Location
nomad... im everywhere and anywhere
Gender
Female
HSC
2006
vick1_zha0 said:
hey s1mplykat

just wondering... how did u travel to penrith on academic advisory day?
did u have to go city first to catch the train?
and one more question how was the academic advisory day? was it important?
hey vick1_zha0, i basically fluked my way there. i caught a bus to central and from central station, i caught a train to kingswood station, initially thinking that the academic advisory day was at werrington south, i headed towards the w.south campus site and took directions from different people and somehow ended up at the kingswood campus. haha.

obut yeah, i missed out on the talk but i got to make friends and get my student id. considering i didnt get there in time to listen to the talk im not too sure if it was all important, but the people i talked to that went to the talk said it wasnt all important, all in all im glad i got to meet people and such..

when orientation and classes for the B Design (vis comm) course commence, we'll be held at werrington south and so to get there via public transport, you will basically have to train it to kingswood station and there should be a UWS shuttle bus that takes you to the werrinton south campus =]
 

vick1_zha0

New Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2005
Messages
7
Location
Unknown
Gender
Female
HSC
2006
Hey s1mplykat
Thanks for the information!! its so informative!!!
so on orientation day.. i'll be cathing the train from central station to kingswood station then!!... haha thanks!!
 

s1mplykat

Member
Joined
Sep 10, 2005
Messages
149
Location
nomad... im everywhere and anywhere
Gender
Female
HSC
2006
vick1_zha0 said:
Hey s1mplykat
Thanks for the information!! its so informative!!!
so on orientation day.. i'll be cathing the train from central station to kingswood station then!!... haha thanks!!
haha, yeah its all good.
yeah, just get to kingswood station and from the station there should be a shuttle bus that you catch that will take you to werrington south. the shuttle bus stop is across the road from the subway shop and it runs half-hourly.. i've never caught it before so im not too sure about what it looks like, but apparently it's titled with UWS SHUTTLE BUS.. so yeah, im pretty sure if we saw it, we'd be able to recognise it..

here's the map & timetable link : http://www.uws.edu.au/about/adminorg/devint/cwf/maps/penrithshuttlebus
 

vick1_zha0

New Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2005
Messages
7
Location
Unknown
Gender
Female
HSC
2006
HeYYY Thanks again for the info!!
btw... we might even be catching the same train and bus together... but we wouldnt know who each other was lol........
 

s1mplykat

Member
Joined
Sep 10, 2005
Messages
149
Location
nomad... im everywhere and anywhere
Gender
Female
HSC
2006
vick1_zha0 said:
HeYYY Thanks again for the info!!
btw... we might even be catching the same train and bus together... but we wouldnt know who each other was lol........
ahah, yeah. but i think i'll be sleeping over my boyfriends house (considering he lives at blacktown) so i might just get a lift there. :) lols, and i soo wanted to go on that darn shuttle bus *hehe.
 

vick1_zha0

New Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2005
Messages
7
Location
Unknown
Gender
Female
HSC
2006
Heyyy,, ur so lucky!!...coz u dun have to sit on the train for an hour!! lol
 

s1mplykat

Member
Joined
Sep 10, 2005
Messages
149
Location
nomad... im everywhere and anywhere
Gender
Female
HSC
2006
vick1_zha0 said:
Heyyy,, ur so lucky!!...coz u dun have to sit on the train for an hour!! lol
ahh, but i will be sitting on a train well over an hour to get to uni wed-thurs.. and anyway my boyfriend (len) and i have been together for over two years now and we see each other practically everyday, he lives in blacktown and i live in randwick, so im pretty much used to the hourly train rides..

if you dont mind me being nosey, what tute times did you pick anyway? im just curious if we picked the same times/days... haha.. how stalker-ish does that sound.. >,<"
 

vick1_zha0

New Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2005
Messages
7
Location
Unknown
Gender
Female
HSC
2006
nahhh i dun mind.... here are all the tute times dat i chose... how about u ?

Unit 101026 - Visual Analysis
Course 1571 - Bachelor of Design (Visual Communication)
School School of Communication Arts


Coordinator Julia Park

Comment Session Day Start Finish location Week Range

Lecture


Wed


11:00


12:00


Werrington South
BBG13

9-16, 18-22
Registered

Tutorial


Thu


10:00


11:00


Werrington South
BJ113

9-16, 18-22
Registered



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Unit 101025 - Australian Design
Course 1571 - Bachelor of Design (Visual Communication)
School School of Communication Arts


Coordinator Alison Gill

Comment Session Day Start Finish location Week Range

Lecture


Tue


13:00


14:00


Werrington South
BBG13

9-16, 18-22
Registered

Tutorial


Tue


14:00


15:00


Werrington South
BJG29

9-16, 18-22
Registered



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Unit 101040 - Approaches to Communication
Course 1571 - Bachelor of Design (Visual Communication)
School School of Communication Arts


Coordinator Stephen Sheehan

Comment Session Day Start Finish location Week Range
If you are unable to register for the lecture, please just attend the first lecture in Week 1.
Lecture


Wed


12:00


13:00


Werrington South
BBG13

9-16, 18-22
Registered

Tutorial


Wed


15:00


16:30


Werrington South
BJ118

9-16, 18-22
Registered



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Unit 101393 - Image: Photomedia
Course 1571 - Bachelor of Design (Visual Communication)
School School of Communication Arts


Coordinator Juliana Swatko

Comment Session Day Start Finish location Week Range

Lecture


Wed


10:00


11:00


Werrington South
BBG13

9-16, 18-22
Registered

Tutorial


Thu


12:00


13:00


Werrington South
BJG30
Werrington South
BJG31-35

9-16, 18-22
Registered
 

groovejet

Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2007
Messages
70
Gender
Male
HSC
N/A
juni said:
Sorry I don't quiet get what you are suggesting here. It seems contradictory in the sense you disagree with Netstar, suggesting it is the 'reality of design' industry that they want degreed grads whilst you don't quiet get why i said 'Most senior/head design positions that are advertised these days specifically asks 'minimum of 4 yrs in a design degree.'
I believe we both have the same belief rather than opposing opinions lol; (Isn't that why you are at UWS doing a 4 years degree in design?)

Just do a quick search for Design related positions at a senior level and you wil find more that says 4 yrs degree and 5 or more yrs of experience etc :)

Obviously it seems logical what DIA has suggested. Would you as an employer choose someone with 4 yrs of study/experience or 2yrs of study/experience? I find it interesting that some employers according to DIA sorts out their potential candiates based on yrs of study and filters out the ones with less experience.
Like what DIA said, if you are serious about design as a career they recommend you to go get a degree, it's not mandatary but you would aspire to if you are serious about getting far. :) If this wasn't true, how do you justify the ridiculously high cut-offs for design at UTS? Or the number of people trying to get into it as well. Also, like what DIA said, most design degrees these days are 4 yrs in length such as the UTS, UNSW and UWS one.

Who wouldn't dream of becoming a CREATIVE DIRECTOR? :D
The universities have consulted with the industry and they believe a four year degree would be beneficial as it give the student time to develop their own projects but I say it clearly, not all individuals or groups require people with a 4 year degree in design. The groups that do probably those highly commerical ones that need to spell it out to make sure there are no insecurities to their business. It does not make any difference if you do a four year degree or not. Have you considered in the other parts of the world where the degree is only 3 years and in fairness much better and more established than the univerisities here that provide a design education? Numbers don't mean anything and considering when not all graduates will not be as serious and highly motivated, I can say groups are looking to self-presentation and the person's ability and personality. Sometimes it's not your work but if you don't have good communication or your arrogant, you won't be successful. Justifying the high cutt-offs for popularity is good but can you actually justify the high-offs for people who do know half of what they are getting into? Half of the people don't even know what they are getting in for and all they care about is when they have tut's in using photoshop. It's fair to give them every good chance but if they don't realise what they are getting into than it's not good for the industry and above all, Australian Design. If the DIA actually want to do something about it than advise (not recommend) universities to provide a foundation art/design course of a 1 year and expose potential students to what is design.

As for am I am concerned, the DIA recommends everything but hasn't help me out in anyway. All you can do as a so called designer is trust your instincts, build a network of people whether be friends or clients and get into contact with studios/agencies. If you want to seek a 4 year degree then go for it. I'm doing it because I'm committed and motivated but you can't say this to everyone single person as maybe it's their only way and it's a formaility for their c.v. Ask Andrew from DIK, it was a waste of time.

Nothing that I said previously is contradictory and I said that the reality of design is to be considered because it's highly competitive and highly saturated especially in Australia and the only key to groups differentiating who should be hired is a good folio. Consider those who have gone to New York at 18 worked as a junior art director or assistant to art director and they are now working their way up with years of experience. These people that I know of did not have any formal education at all and they become successful. They believed that they believed they had confidence and the employer in the role. Be successful in any role means more than a piece of paper: being able to sell yourself but having good verbal skills, being presentable and above all, having a good personality and keeping in contacts with clients.

Everyone has a different direction but I'm going with my instincts, building a network of people I know of that can assist me and be motivated enough to seek opportunities. Having a four degree paper doesn't add any credibility when you have nothing to show for it. Now sorry, I've got to worry about my own skin than helping everyone else.

Who wants to be a creative director? So you can earn $100,000+ or more and think your better than everyone and be overbearing in a over commericalised company? No thanks, I'll rather be humber and thankful when I'm older and be grateful for what I have achieved like Ken Garland or working individuals like Paul Rand.
 
Last edited:

s1mplykat

Member
Joined
Sep 10, 2005
Messages
149
Location
nomad... im everywhere and anywhere
Gender
Female
HSC
2006
vick1_zha0 said:
nahhh i dun mind.... here are all the tute times dat i chose... how about u ?

Unit 101026 - Visual Analysis
Course 1571 - Bachelor of Design (Visual Communication)
School School of Communication Arts


Coordinator Julia Park

Comment Session Day Start Finish location Week Range

Lecture


Wed


11:00


12:00


Werrington South
BBG13

9-16, 18-22
Registered

Tutorial


Thu


10:00


11:00


Werrington South
BJ113

9-16, 18-22
Registered



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Unit 101025 - Australian Design
Course 1571 - Bachelor of Design (Visual Communication)
School School of Communication Arts


Coordinator Alison Gill

Comment Session Day Start Finish location Week Range

Lecture


Tue


13:00


14:00


Werrington South
BBG13

9-16, 18-22
Registered

Tutorial


Tue


14:00


15:00


Werrington South
BJG29

9-16, 18-22
Registered



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Unit 101040 - Approaches to Communication
Course 1571 - Bachelor of Design (Visual Communication)
School School of Communication Arts


Coordinator Stephen Sheehan

Comment Session Day Start Finish location Week Range
If you are unable to register for the lecture, please just attend the first lecture in Week 1.
Lecture


Wed


12:00


13:00


Werrington South
BBG13

9-16, 18-22
Registered

Tutorial


Wed


15:00


16:30


Werrington South
BJ118

9-16, 18-22
Registered



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Unit 101393 - Image: Photomedia
Course 1571 - Bachelor of Design (Visual Communication)
School School of Communication Arts


Coordinator Juliana Swatko

Comment Session Day Start Finish location Week Range

Lecture


Wed


10:00


11:00


Werrington South
BBG13

9-16, 18-22
Registered

Tutorial


Thu


12:00


13:00


Werrington South
BJG30
Werrington South
BJG31-35

9-16, 18-22
Registered
hah, mine are:
Tues:
1pm-2pm Aust Design Lecture.BBG13
3pm-4pm Aust Design Tutorial.BJG29

Wed:
10am-11am Image: Photomedia Lecture.BBG13
11am-12pm Visual Analysis Lecture.BBG13
12pm-1pm Approaches to Communication Lecture.BBG13

Thurs:
11am-12pm Image: Photomedia Tutorial.BJG30/ BJG31-35
12pm-1pm Visual Analysis Tutorial.BJ113
3.30pm-5pm Approaches to Communication Tutorial.BB109/BB110

we didnt rego for any of the same tute times.. haha, allwells... guess i'll just see you in lectures =]

hey do you know if our orrientation is just the one day? or does it go on for a whole week?
 

vick1_zha0

New Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2005
Messages
7
Location
Unknown
Gender
Female
HSC
2006
lol alright ill c u in lectures den!!
ummm... im not sure i think its only 1 day...
 

juni

juni
Joined
Jan 6, 2005
Messages
66
Location
Sydney
Gender
Female
HSC
2003
groovejet said:
The universities have consulted with the industry and they believe a four year degree would be beneficial as it give the student time to develop their own projects but I say it clearly, not all individuals or groups require people with a 4 year degree in design. The groups that do probably those highly commerical ones that need to spell it out to make sure there are no insecurities to their business. It does not make any difference if you do a four year degree or not. Have you considered in the other parts of the world where the degree is only 3 years and in fairness much better and more established than the univerisities here that provide a design education? Numbers don't mean anything and considering when not all graduates will not be as serious and highly motivated, I can say groups are looking to self-presentation and the person's ability and personality. Sometimes it's not your work but if you don't have good communication or your arrogant, you won't be successful. Justifying the high cutt-offs for popularity is good but can you actually justify the high-offs for people who do know half of what they are getting into? Half of the people don't even know what they are getting in for and all they care about is when they have tut's in using photoshop. It's fair to give them every good chance but if they don't realise what they are getting into than it's not good for the industry and above all, Australian Design. If the DIA actually want to do something about it than advise (not recommend) universities to provide a foundation art/design course of a 1 year and expose potential students to what is design.

As for am I am concerned, the DIA recommends everything but hasn't help me out in anyway. All you can do as a so called designer is trust your instincts, build a network of people whether be friends or clients and get into contact with studios/agencies. If you want to seek a 4 year degree then go for it. I'm doing it because I'm committed and motivated but you can't say this to everyone single person as maybe it's their only way and it's a formaility for their c.v. Ask Andrew from DIK, it was a waste of time.

Nothing that I said previously is contradictory and I said that the reality of design is to be considered because it's highly competitive and highly saturated especially in Australia and the only key to groups differentiating who should be hired is a good folio. Consider those who have gone to New York at 18 worked as a junior art director or assistant to art director and they are now working their way up with years of experience. These people that I know of did not have any formal education at all and they become successful. They believed that they believed they had confidence and the employer in the role. Be successful in any role means more than a piece of paper: being able to sell yourself but having good verbal skills, being presentable and above all, having a good personality and keeping in contacts with clients.

Everyone has a different direction but I'm going with my instincts, building a network of people I know of that can assist me and be motivated enough to seek opportunities. Having a four degree paper doesn't add any credibility when you have nothing to show for it. Now sorry, I've got to worry about my own skin than helping everyone else.

Who wants to be a creative director? So you can earn $100,000+ or more and think your better than everyone and be overbearing in a over commericalised company? No thanks, I'll rather be humber and thankful when I'm older and be grateful for what I have achieved like Ken Garland or working individuals like Paul Rand.
i never expected this to be this long of a discussion lol

i dont think i ever supsected your design capabilities so... I don't know why the dicussion is somehow leading towards judging one's 'talent'. I only mentioned the uts cut-off for this thread actually is about TRANSFERING from UWS to UTS. Nor should you be generalising suggesting half the ppl at UTS design are clueless and only doing it to play with photoshop. (by what evidence is this anyway, i must disagree on this, most people are talented and have been recognised for their creativity at high school level before choosing to continue their studies at a university to begin with)

'Having a four degree paper doesn't add any credibility when you have nothing to show for it.' This is rather funny.. Um..Would you actually have passed and graduated from a 4 yrs degree if you really had nothing at all to show from all the works done for 4 years plus work experience?.......A degree means alot acutally..How can you undermine what a degree holds when you have experienced university education on your own..This is rather a disrepect to anybody who went through an university education. It can represent self commitment , dedication etc.

Also.. you do realise design is an applied/commercial form of art....right?
 
Last edited:

msh

Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2007
Messages
133
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2004
Now now let’s not get sidetracked.
This discussion went off track since netstar’s random post on saying that how we should go to private schools/tafe for design in a transfer discussion thread.
I like what hellomike said about private design schools and simplycat agreed to that like I do.
I brought up the DIA’s view on this which settled this point that none of us here thinks private schools/tafe are the way to go about design lol and DIA doesn’t either considering they recommend a 4 years university degree. So I don’t care if anybody tries to discourage me from aiming higher (whats wrong with tryin to better yourself anyway?@!) I rather be safe then take a risky route.

So back to the REAL ISSUE. CAN WE ACTUALLY GET IN? :(
I got REJECTD this year like some other BOS ppl from uws.
I had a uai of 80, and a lowish credit average and as you can see I researched A LOT about design and obviously we are trying to transfer to UTS to better our selves and survive in this competitive industry. But they still rejected me =_= I think im talented so im not gonna give up. I thought i did quiet well in the interview.. oh well gotta do better :(

Hopefully i'll be in the top 10 applicants next year (dammit why do they pick so little :confused: :confused: :confused: )

I know someone who got a uai of 86 and was trasnfering from UNSW design and she got rejected as well.wtf??
Does anybody here actually know of those who got in from UWS? :( can they share some tips with us lol
Thanks and best wishes to everyone that’s trying out for it :) im gonna try again next year
 

Kaiyn

New Member
Joined
Apr 26, 2005
Messages
11
Gender
Male
HSC
2007
K firstly, To S1mplykat..

Of course it is possible :)
Speaking as a student who got into uts visual communications through internal course transfer (it's the same process), the interviewers are looking for students who have a real passion for the feild. They look for it in the quality of your work obviously, and your previous years results. For these you will need at least a C average and also ignore any limitations on the number of works you can bring in (this is what the interviewers told me), but on the other hand don't bring in just anything thinking "oh well can't hurt," because it really can diminish your chances, bring only your absolute best work and if you can have someone with experience look atit first. Other ways to get across to them are through things such as work experience and short courses (which will also help you build a portfolio) and most importantly, the written statement. This allows you a vehicle in which you can perfectly convey everything you need to about yourself, basically you need to sell yourself here (why do you deserve this?). Also keep up a professional practice, go to exhibitions ect, they will probably ask you about this...have opinions. Lastly i think it's also a very good idea to make yourself known. Email the faculty, come in, ask advice ect. Get yourself known, it shows a real determination :)

Thats all i can think of on that issue right now lol.

Secondly, im sorry but i can't ignore this...


groovejet said:
The universities have consulted with the industry and they believe a four year degree would be beneficial as it give the student time to develop their own projects but I say it clearly, not all individuals or groups require people with a 4 year degree in design. The groups that do probably those highly commerical ones that need to spell it out to make sure there are no insecurities to their business. It does not make any difference if you do a four year degree or not. Have you considered in the other parts of the world where the degree is only 3 years and in fairness much better and more established than the univerisities here that provide a design education? Numbers don't mean anything and considering when not all graduates will not be as serious and highly motivated, I can say groups are looking to self-presentation and the person's ability and personality. Sometimes it's not your work but if you don't have good communication or your arrogant, you won't be successful. Justifying the high cutt-offs for popularity is good but can you actually justify the high-offs for people who do know half of what they are getting into? Half of the people don't even know what they are getting in for and all they care about is when they have tut's in using photoshop. It's fair to give them every good chance but if they don't realise what they are getting into than it's not good for the industry and above all, Australian Design. If the DIA actually want to do something about it than advise (not recommend) universities to provide a foundation art/design course of a 1 year and expose potential students to what is design.

As for am I am concerned, the DIA recommends everything but hasn't help me out in anyway. All you can do as a so called designer is trust your instincts, build a network of people whether be friends or clients and get into contact with studios/agencies. If you want to seek a 4 year degree then go for it. I'm doing it because I'm committed and motivated but you can't say this to everyone single person as maybe it's their only way and it's a formaility for their c.v. Ask Andrew from DIK, it was a waste of time.

Nothing that I said previously is contradictory and I said that the reality of design is to be considered because it's highly competitive and highly saturated especially in Australia and the only key to groups differentiating who should be hired is a good folio. Consider those who have gone to New York at 18 worked as a junior art director or assistant to art director and they are now working their way up with years of experience. These people that I know of did not have any formal education at all and they become successful. They believed that they believed they had confidence and the employer in the role. Be successful in any role means more than a piece of paper: being able to sell yourself but having good verbal skills, being presentable and above all, having a good personality and keeping in contacts with clients.

Everyone has a different direction but I'm going with my instincts, building a network of people I know of that can assist me and be motivated enough to seek opportunities. Having a four degree paper doesn't add any credibility when you have nothing to show for it. Now sorry, I've got to worry about my own skin than helping everyone else.

Who wants to be a creative director? So you can earn $100,000+ or more and think your better than everyone and be overbearing in a over commericalised company? No thanks, I'll rather be humber and thankful when I'm older and be grateful for what I have achieved like Ken Garland or working individuals like Paul Rand.
First off, you seem to use this word "commercial" alot as if it is a certain section of the design feild, but what you must understand is design IS commercial. Designers make products, and those products must sell. It's a fundamental fact that seperates artists and designers. In order for products to sell, you must accept the "commercial" nature of the feild.

It most definitely does make a difference wether or not you undertake a four year degree. Yes of course there maybe some exceptions where amazingly talented people work there way to the top without a degree but that shouldn't be confused with what is the standard. Simply speaking logically, an employer would rather someone with more experience than less, and most importantly, it is these 4 years that allow you to build an impressive portfolio under the guidance of people from the feild itself.

Ok, now im sorry but your comment about how half the people in the degree don't know what there in for and simply come along for photoshop tutes is complete rubish. If you actually had attended a uts design class you would realise that the standard is VERY high and that you are infact surrounded by a group of highly motivated people who know EXACTLY where they are headed, for example, i have a friend who has, before even starting uni, illustrated a published book. She has allways known where she is headed. People don't come in to learn photoshop, they already intimately know it, they have been practicing for years. This is the standard of design at UTS.

It's also important to mention that i don't know how you consider the reputation of UTS overseas as opposed to these "3 year...much better" courses, but i think if you read any comments from overseas sources you will find things like "An elite group of design students that are incomparable [to others in the feild]." Yes, a network of supporters is good, but it wont get you to where you need to be alone.

Lastly i'd like to make it clear than a creative director doesn't THINK they are better than other designers, they ARE among the most highly skilled in their proffession as they have accomplished years of training both at university level and in the industry and are as such rightfully at one of the highest levels attainable in the feild.

LOL sorry for my insanely long post but it everything that i fealt i had to say, and S1mplykat, i hope you find this usefull :)

Good Luck!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top