What are your thoughts on the NSW education system? (10 Viewers)

[spiderfan44]

Bruh did you miss the part where I was talking about the funding required to maintain a school... Student fees won't pay for that. Maybe a GPS school but not the majority of private schools in the state.

if the school cant be maintained then i dont think they should be propped up by the government. if the school cant function i think it should be converted into public

 

[Average Boreduser]

if the school cant be maintained then i dont think they should be propped up by the government. if the school cant function i think it should be converted into public

There would then be discrepancies on how said 'extra funding' would be distributed. Selective schools especially are known to force students to do 14Units to receive extra funding from the government. Corruption in the government sectors (enhanced by extra funding) would only cause more of a divide. It's a hit or miss if a certain school would receive the same as one who has essentially cheated the system. A communist style regime for schools would do nothing towards the gap for rural either because theres much more to it than just strictly funding. Private schools don't have this problem which is why families fork out that extra $ to provide their children with education that is guaranteed/promised to lead to students getting the most out of opportunities available.

 

[KloppsAndRobbers]

if the school cant be maintained then i dont think they should be propped up by the government. if the school cant function i think it should be converted into public

What? So the government should allow hundreds of relatively poor private schools across NSW to close? Do you even fathom the implications of that? The government aids several sectors across the economy that aren't public; what's so bad about funding schools? It's not like they're propping up Sydney Grammar or Knox lol.

 

[axe]

if the school cant be maintained then i dont think they should be propped up by the government. if the school cant function i think it should be converted into public

a private school is cheaper for the government than a pub school. chances are that people who go to private schools inadvertently fund public schools more than you do. win win for everyone.

 

[axe]

you don't always get the benefits. im a boarder and bc ive done y12 in a city i don't get it for quite a few unis. usyd also uses government classifications of the areas to determine who is regional/rurual

yeah cause you board in the city you shouldnt have an excuse if your atar doesnt meet your course. my point is the fact that people still get rural benefits for boarding is a bit ridiculous.

 

[axe]

the tutoring i get is not very quality.

i can tell

 

[jonolad69]

i can tell

visual arts and investigating science tutoring going crazy

 

[katiekms]

visual arts and investigating science tutoring going crazy

english and maths tutoring thanks. i’m first in both of those subjects, so obviously i’m doing alright.

 

[jonolad69]

english and maths tutoring thanks. i’m first in both of those subjects, so obviously i’m doing alright.

top 400 school, first isn't a flex.

 

[spiderfan44]

What? So the government should allow hundreds of relatively poor private schools across NSW to close? Do you even fathom the implications of that? The government aids several sectors across the economy that aren't public; what's so bad about funding schools? It's not like they're propping up Sydney Grammar or Knox lol.

 

[axe]

View attachment 43957View attachment 43958

a public school gets more funding from govt??? i do not see your point

 

[beanbug]

yeah cause you board in the city you shouldnt have an excuse if your atar doesnt meet your course. my point is the fact that people still get rural benefits for boarding is a bit ridiculous.

well i did the first 11 years of my schooling in a regional area and there was a really big difference between me and my peers when i first started y11. i had a fair bit of catching up to do and my grades weren't the best. the reason regional and rural students still get benefits even if they board is because the earlier years of high school have an impact on how you perform in y11&12 and also being a boarder is so difficult compared to being a day kid, especially with travel

 

[Bastani]

well i did the first 11 years of my schooling in a regional area and there was a really big difference between me and my peers when i first started y11. i had a fair bit of catching up to do and my grades weren't the best. the reason regional and rural students still get benefits even if they board is because the earlier years of high school have an impact on how you perform in y11&12 and also being a boarder is so difficult compared to being a day kid, especially with travel

ok thanks

 

[Average Boreduser]

well i did the first 11 years of my schooling in a regional area and there was a really big difference between me and my peers when i first started y11. i had a fair bit of catching up to do and my grades weren't the best. the reason regional and rural students still get benefits even if they board is because the earlier years of high school have an impact on how you perform in y11&12 and also being a boarder is so difficult compared to being a day kid, especially with travel

If that's the case, you are still eligible from my understanding (definately for med, that is the case).

 

[Bastani]

If that's the case, you are still eligible from my understanding (definately for med, that is the case).

thanks mate

 

[Average Boreduser]

thanks mate

your welcom.e

 

[[ ]]

From a sociological point of view, the urban/city debate on NSW education is more complicated than people think. Yes, you can even get state-ranked, but it's the case of whether you have acquired the cultural capital you need, to know how to succeed in your HSC, on a case-by-case circumstance. Lack of motivation probably is also part of the equation. However, I know some of my friends who actually cared but didn't even know how to take notes. They would literally try to write every word my teacher said.

 

[Aeonium]

i can’t get a 91 with 0 b6s

cos of your subjects, other ppl can

don’t you think that if rural people truely were at an advantage, rich people wanting to do med would move to rural areas? go to school at rural schools? or deep down do we all understand that rural education gives you a disadvantage.

this is a bit of a bad argument. moving to rural areas (or anywhere really) is a massive hassle for just med. rural education does give you a disadvantage but the change in med cutoffs defo overcompensates. in terms of the actual disadvantage though, i'm curious. what do you think hinders you? your teachers? your environment?

 

[Bastani]

From a sociological point of view, the urban/city debate on NSW education is more complicated than people think. Yes, you can even get state-ranked, but it's the case of whether you have acquired the cultural capital you need, to know how to succeed in your HSC, on a case-by-case circumstance. Lack of motivation probably is also part of the equation. However, I know some of my friends who actually cared but didn't even know how to take notes. They would literally try to write every word my teacher said.

can it make ts shorter im not reading all that

 

[Aeonium]

i think we’re gonna have to agree to disagree

i think you're just wrong lowkey

tutoring costs money. the only reason i can get tutoring is because i got a scholarship that pays for it, but even with that, it can only get me 25 min sessions for two subjects once a week, and costs like a quarter of the price of dr du. the tutoring i get is not very quality. but obviously i have to make do. also picking subjects that scale well is not as easy as you make it out to be - nobody at my school even knew about how scaling worked or atars or anything like that, we only chose what we enjoyed. i only really learned about stuff like that this year.

tutoring does not make that big of a difference. also with scaling, i feel like the onus is up to the student to do their research, same with university and every other major decision in your life. maybe i'm cynical but everyone says to pick the subjects you will do best in/enjoy so like ???