Predictions for Modern? (12 Viewers)

[karamazova]

Does anyone know how necessary historians are for section 4, should I spend some time learning some?

it’s not really necessary, historiography isn’t on the marking guidelines for modern history & i asked my teacher (who’s an hsc marker) about it and she agreed you don’t need them to do well in the hsc, but it also doesn’t hurt to know the historiography of your topic because that can inform and reinforce your judgements : )

https://www.sl.nsw.gov.au/learning/hsc-2024/hsc-history/exam-qa-hsc-modern-history has a little more info

 

[karamazova]

idk if anyone else does ancient history but the historiography aspect always trips me up for revision because they’re integral to ancient but negligible for modern

 

[cheeseburger100]

any predictions for USA maybe?

 

[radagastthebrown]

idk if anyone else does ancient history but the historiography aspect always trips me up for revision because they’re integral to ancient but negligible for modern

I do ancient and for some reason I always thought the opposite (which is super wrong), took me so long to learn that I was doing it wrong, probably explains my rank for Ancient. I always get stuck on trying to remember the primary sources too, which are especially useful in the short answer for Ancient, that also explains why I've never been able to break past 80-85% on anything I write in Ancient.

 

[karamazova]

I do ancient and for some reason I always thought the opposite (which is super wrong), took me so long to learn that I was doing it wrong, probably explains my rank for Ancient. I always get stuck on trying to remember the primary sources too, which are especially useful in the short answer for Ancient, that also explains why I've never been able to break past 80-85% on anything I write in Ancient.

oh no! good that you caught it before the hsc exams though

 

[hihglightermmmm]

Final predictions for russia + pacific?>

 

[zepplu]

some predictions for usa national study: attempts to halt the gd and growth of consumerism or industrialisation

 

[cheerios435435]

for russia do you think it is likely one of the questions will be on the impact of political transformation, and the other one on totalitarianism

 

[cheerios435435]

and for Indochina i think one question will be on strategies and tactics -- did they technically ask reasons for communist victory in vietnam for the 2021 HSC?

 

[earlgreyteawithmilkfoam]

for russia do you think it is likely one of the questions will be on the impact of political transformation, and the other one on totalitarianism

uhhhh i'd say they both have a good chance, but i'd bank on there being a q from the first three dotpoints

 

[earlgreyteawithmilkfoam]

and for Indochina i think one question will be on strategies and tactics -- did they technically ask reasons for communist victory in vietnam for the 2021 HSC?

yeah comm victory was basically asked in 2021

 

[cheerios435435]

uhhhh i'd say they both have a good chance, but i'd bank on there being a q from the first three dotpoints

what can they ask about bolshevik consolidation of power though since they asked it in 2020
is it likely they could ask "evaluate the importance of ideology during the bolshevik consolidation of power?" or no bc they did ideology in 2021

 

[earlgreyteawithmilkfoam]

what can they ask about bolshevik consolidation of power though since they asked it in 2020
is it likely they could ask "evaluate the importance of ideology during the bolshevik consolidation of power?" or no bc they did ideology in 2021

i mean i don't see what's preventing them from repeating qs icl considering most things have been asked, it's been a while since the earlier dotpoints were asked asw. they also can re-use key features, they cld ask ab the role of ideology/competing visions in shaping the power struggle or consolidation of power. they could combine dotpoints and ask ab the role of consolidation of power in stalin's emergence as leader for all ik.

someone also pointed they haven't asked directly ab the creation of the USSR, which is a part of the consolidation of power dotpoint so yeah

 

[utopianimal]

i mean i don't see what's preventing them from repeating qs icl considering most things have been asked, it's been a while since the earlier dotpoints were asked asw. they also can re-use key features, they cld ask ab the role of ideology/competing visions in shaping the power struggle or consolidation of power. they could combine dotpoints and ask ab the role of consolidation of power in stalin's emergence as leader for all ik.

someone also pointed they haven't asked directly ab the creation of the USSR, which is a part of the consolidation of power dotpoint so yeah

have they asked abt treaty of brest litovsk, civil war, NEP??

 

[utopianimal]

aye for my apartheid students, what would u write for this dot point plsss

IMPACT OF APARTHEID ON RURAL AND URBAN COMMUNITIES

 

[cheerios435435]

also how did people structure paragraphs for impact of war on civilians in Vietnam? e.g. by economic, socio-cultural, environmental or political impacts or somethign else

 

[karamazova]

have they asked abt treaty of brest litovsk, civil war, NEP??

not directly because those are part of the survey section, but it does relate to the impact of the Bolshevik consolidation of power

 

[earlgreyteawithmilkfoam]

have they asked abt treaty of brest litovsk, civil war, NEP??

they haven't, but it's not explicitly in the dotpoint unlike 'creation of the USSR', hmm i mean whilst it's not impossible they could ask about those events as they are part of consol of power period, idk if they wld but again its nesa so who knows

 

[karamazova]

also how did people structure paragraphs for impact of war on civilians in Vietnam? e.g. by economic, socio-cultural, environmental or political impacts or somethign else

political, economic, social/cultural, human/environmental impacts!

 

[earlgreyteawithmilkfoam]

not directly because those are part of the survey section, but it does relate to the impact of the Bolshevik consolidation of power

ohh mb yeah i didn't realise they explicitly listed in the survey that's MB, yeah if its listed in the survey, i doubt they'd directly ask about it