Does God exist? (10 Viewers)

[nikolas]

god talked to me. he was in a bush. that was burning.
whats so hard to understand

...

 

[Elite.Meat]

...

ok. new thought experiment. say god came to my front door and performed miracles for me then told me i was saved, and then i came told you, would you believe me then?

 

[CyanideChrist]

why not?

How do I know you're not lying? How do you know the bush isn't lying?

ok. new thought experiment. say god came to my front door and performed miracles for me then told me i was saved, and then i came told you, would you believe me then?

See above.

god talked to me. he was in a bush. that was burning.
whats so hard to understand

OH MY FUCKING GOD ROFL!!!

 

[nikolas]

ok. new thought experiment. say god came to my front door and performed miracles for me then told me i was saved, and then i came told you, would you believe me then?

I don't think even if i were christian I'd believe you.

OH MY FUCKING GOD ROFL!!!

relax she's only in yr 7 =\

 

[Elite.Meat]

OH MY FUCKING GOD ROFL!!!

i didnt actually see it. its ok. its a thought experiment.

so even if hundreds of people had witnessed these miracles, would you believe me then?

 

[genericusername]

relax she's only in yr 7 =\

No, it's a troll.

 

[nikolas]

i didnt actually see it. its ok. its a thought experiment.

so even if hundreds of people had witnessed these miracles, would you believe me then?

Well the miracles would have to be proven to be a miracles 1st. Off which there are none proven miracles.

No, it's a troll.

I dunno, trolls usually give off an aura of stupidity, she seems more naive than stupid.

 

[CyanideChrist]

i didnt actually see it. its ok. its a thought experiment.

It was still hilarious.

so even if hundreds of people had witnessed these miracles, would you believe me then?

No, lol. Same reasons as before.

 

[Elite.Meat]

Well the miracles would have to be proven to be a miracles 1st. Off which there are none proven miracles.

so, say some bloke who was blind, could see? is that a miracle?
what about if someone with a mental disease was suddenly normal?

 

[nikolas]

so, say some bloke who was blind, could see? is that a miracle?
what about if someone with a mental disease was suddenly normal?

Not if there are naturalistic explanations.

 

[Elite.Meat]

Not if there are naturalistic explanations.

but if someone said like, 'let you be healed', then these "naturalistic explanations", as you happen to call them occured, is that a miracle?

 

[nikolas]

but if someone said like, 'let you be healed', then these "naturalistic explanations", as you happen to call them occured, is that a miracle?

Id call it a massive coincidence.



Btw your not about to cite faith healers as proof of God?

 

[Elite.Meat]

Id call it a massive coincidence.



Btw your not about to cite faith healers as proof of God?

a massive coincidence? even if it occurs to the same person numerous times?


who are faith healers?

 

[CyanideChrist]

a massive coincidence? even if it occurs to the same person numerous times?

It's certainly not proof of god, if that's what you're implying (which you are)...

 

[nikolas]

a massive coincidence? even if it occurs to the same person numerous times?

Well assuming it actually happened...

who are faith healers?

People who say "let you be healed" and someone apparently gets healed.

 

[Elite.Meat]

It's certainly not proof of god, if that's what you're implying (which you are)...

I'll get to that later.

so say if this person had this ability, you would say he had a special power, no?

 

[Elite.Meat]

Well assuming it actually happened...

he'd have to have some special knowledge, some sort of supernatural power?

 

[nikolas]

I'll get to that later.

so say if this person had this ability, you would say he had a special power, no?

he'd have to have some special knowledge, some sort of supernatural power?

Well if these miracles/faith heals actually happened, i suppose so.

But this is all irrelevant since no miracles have been proven.

 

[Elite.Meat]

Well if these miracles/faith heals actually happened, i suppose so.

so you may ask where these miracles come from?

you may actually record these miracles too?

 

[nikolas]

so you may ask where these miracles come from?

you may actually record these miracles too?

Irrelevant, just because someone believes a miracle and writes it in a book does not add to your argument in any sort of way.