World Idol (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter Survivor39
- Start date
im not sure if its smart move by channel 10 to show american idol
becuz when it finishes, they have to aussie idol, and ppl mite get bored of idol by then.
think about it, we finished our first idol series, then they showed world idol, and then they're gonna show american idol, so when we do get up to aussie idol, ppl mite be sick of idol. but i can be wrong and it could go the other way
another bad thing from showin american idol is the publicity the winner will get from us. and when it comes time for the third world idol(if it makes it there) the aussies will be more inclined to vote fot the american idol, givin our third idol (once again, if we make it there) less of a chance
becuz when it finishes, they have to aussie idol, and ppl mite get bored of idol by then.
think about it, we finished our first idol series, then they showed world idol, and then they're gonna show american idol, so when we do get up to aussie idol, ppl mite be sick of idol. but i can be wrong and it could go the other way
another bad thing from showin american idol is the publicity the winner will get from us. and when it comes time for the third world idol(if it makes it there) the aussies will be more inclined to vote fot the american idol, givin our third idol (once again, if we make it there) less of a chance
Last edited:
routemarker
Looking for the Way out ?
or American Idol will make Australian Idol look really inferior...
i think it's great that they're airing it so we get to have a taste of what their show is like compared to ours, and im thinking its gonna be much better. think about it, how much did the Aussie version of Survivor and Fear Factor suck?? better off that they show it than not at all, we missed out on the first two so at least we get the third. and besides, channel 10 decided to show it because of its potential massive ratings.
Survivor39
Premium Member
- Joined
- May 23, 2003
- Messages
- 4,467
- Gender
- Undisclosed
- HSC
- 2003
The third Idol is like next year in 2005....I don't think it will make that much of a difference.
and I don't agree with what you're saying. Showing American will only improve the quality of our own idol. I mean look at Guy. 7th our of 11 in World Idol, which reflect how crap our Idol through worldwide perspective.
I want to see American Idol 1
PrettyNoose
New Member
- Joined
- Oct 7, 2003
- Messages
- 0
- Gender
- Female
- HSC
- 2005
stickied? people must like their idol
when i said it was bad, i meant it might be bad for channel 10 in terms of their ratings when it comes time to show aussie idol. ofcourse american idol will attract viewers, but i just thought it might be a possibility that ppl will get sick of watching so much idol, but i also said i could be wrong and it could go the other wayOriginally posted by Survivor39
The third Idol is like next year in 2005....I don't think it will make that much of a difference.
and I don't agree with what you're saying. Showing American will only improve the quality of our own idol. I mean look at Guy. 7th our of 11 in World Idol, which reflect how crap our Idol through worldwide perspective.
I want to see American Idol 1
and i wouldn't use the world idol comp as an indication of how good or bad our competition is
Last edited:
Survivor39
Premium Member
- Joined
- May 23, 2003
- Messages
- 4,467
- Gender
- Undisclosed
- HSC
- 2003
Yeah. I sticky threads which have over 200 replies OR over 2000 views.
well is that the case for Survivor? It is up to Seasons 7 now and the ratings has remained constant.
I think it is a very good indication to show the standard of competition.
you can't say the ratings hav eremained constant from the start though? the first was a hit! the second was going down but still some watched it, and now i don't know anyone who watches it. i don't even know why it airs.
Survivor39
Premium Member
- Joined
- May 23, 2003
- Messages
- 4,467
- Gender
- Undisclosed
- HSC
- 2003
the reason it is still airing is because people are still watching it! Simple!...Do you think NINE is stupid enough to buy the series and air it at prime time so that not many people will watch it??!
The reason why i think Survivor and Idol are different is because channel 9 shows Survivor once a year, however channel 10 have shown the first aussie idol, then after that world idol, then after that american idol, so when it comes time to show the second aussie idol ppl mite be bored of idol because they haven't had a break from it
i still disagree, because many ppl (guy fans and non-guy fans) have said that the standard of competition at world idol was bad, and i think it was u who said that the belguin guy was really bad (im not sure if it was u) but he still beat most of the idols
Survivor39
Premium Member
- Joined
- May 23, 2003
- Messages
- 4,467
- Gender
- Undisclosed
- HSC
- 2003
The standard of competition is World Idol was fierce. The only reason that people don't realise this is because the song choice didn't allow all the idols to show their potential. If you go download each Idols' winner singles, that is Guy - Angels Brought Me Here, Kelly Clarkson 'A Moment Like This' etc... you will see how each of them really sings.
As to the Belgium Peter, I said his image is bad. But I still don't like that genre of music.
routemarker
Looking for the Way out ?
Channel 9 Shows 2 Survivor seasons a yr
[ie, Survivor: Amazon (Spring) and Survivor Pearl Is (Fall/Autumn) for 2003]
when a good show is made in the US they usually have 2 seasons a yr but Simon fuller stopped FOX from doing the same with American Idol because it would dry out too fast and the previous winner wont have alot of time to sell their albums before another winner is created...
Last edited: