MCQ help (1 Viewer)

Bob99

temporarylol hater
Joined
Apr 1, 2022
Messages
230
Gender
Male
HSC
2022
Screen Shot 2022-09-24 at 08.53.51.png
Can someone explain why the answer is A.
I thought the speed decreases and hence frequency increases c=fλ (B).
 

Run hard@thehsc

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2021
Messages
784
Gender
Male
HSC
2022
idk also shouldn't frequency remain the same? cos only wavelength decreases to account for the decreasing speed? idk correct me if I am wrong pls
 

tyrone97

Member
Joined
Sep 10, 2014
Messages
43
Gender
Male
HSC
2014
I think the answer should be C (no change in frequency, speed decreases)

The frequency of any wave never changes when it moves into a different medium. This is because the frequency is dependent only on the source of the wave. Another way of seeing this is that if the photon frequency changes (i'm switching to the "particle" view of light only to illustrate this point), then its energy has changed which would violate conservation of energy.

The only things that are allowed to change are the speed and the wavelength.

Since the wave is bending towards the normal, it must be moving into a more optically dense medium and therefore slowing down (Snell's Law). The wavelength decreases.
 

Bob99

temporarylol hater
Joined
Apr 1, 2022
Messages
230
Gender
Male
HSC
2022
I think the answer should be C (no change in frequency, speed decreases)

The frequency of any wave never changes when it moves into a different medium. This is because the frequency is dependent only on the source of the wave. Another way of seeing this is that if the photon frequency changes (i'm switching to the "particle" view of light only to illustrate this point), then its energy has changed which would violate conservation of energy.

The only things that are allowed to change are the speed and the wavelength.

Since the wave is bending towards the normal, it must be moving into a more optically dense medium and therefore slowing down (Snell's Law). The wavelength decreases.
Thank you for your explanation!
And damn the QAT paper has so many mistakes in its solutions.
 

wizzkids

Active Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2016
Messages
253
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
1998
Yes, that answer sheet must be wrong. Frequency never changes when a light wave passes between two different mediums.
Think of it this way: Crests and troughs are arriving at the interface.
(i) If the frequency is going to increase on the other side of the interface, where are these extra crests and troughs going to magically appear from???
(ii) If the frequency is going to decrease on the other side of the interface, that means crests and troughs are going to accumulate at the interface. That can't be right either.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top