And the winner is..................... American Idol [FINAL TWO] (1 Viewer)

[Survivor39]

Ryan: Ok Diana, last night, Randy said 'you sang unbelievably', Simon said 'it was good, but not good enough to be the American Idol', Paula said 'you did great'. Fantasia, last night Randy said 'you are the American Idol'. Simon said 'if America got it right, they would vote for you'. Paula said 'I've got nothing more to say' you got it all, you got it all'.
Over 200 million votes put you two here on this stage tonight. I will tell you it was a 52/48 split. America has made their decision. Diana, Fantasia *pause* the winner of American Idol 2004 is......................................

 

[Iunny]

la toya london!

 

[Survivor39]

Oops sorry, I deleted the other thread with no poll. But this is the one.

 

[iambored]

i can't choose, i'm not voting

 

[bubz :D]

hahah yeah i was thinking, wtf i thought i posted in this?

umm diana

 

[cyrax83]

fantasia looks a little scary

 

[sukiyaki]

going for diana

 

[santaslayer]

Fantasia: Best voice, worst looks, is married

Diana: Occasional good voice, crap body, tends to shout, but young.

Jasmine: Should of won. Good looks, good singong voice, hawwt. America can't vote!


Final Verdict: Fantasia, although her looks scare me.

 

[glycerine]

it's reeeally nice to know that you pick looks over actual, you know, competence as a performer

i agree, fantasia does look slightly scary, but the last american idol wasn't exactly a catch either.

 

[ay_caramba]

fantasia!!

 

[RUB!X]

fantasia should win now ... u g l y
lotoya should have won ...
and the rest arent that good ...

 

[ay_caramba]

yeah, latoya was the best ... i also liked george!
but out of fantasia and diana, fantasia is obviously the one with the better voice, and i like her personality too

 

[~*HSC 4 life*~]

they're both prety crap, i'm dissapointed with the final 2

 

[eLmo]

fantasia!

 

[~ForAGoodCause~]

yea i cant choose cos i dont like any of them

but i think Fantasia will win, they seem to love her

 

[hipsta_jess]

Originally posted by santaslayer
Diana: crap body

i think diana has a good body, shes showing all the impressionable little 13 yr olds out there that you dont have to be a size two to be able to do well.

 

[babydoll_]

Originally posted by cyrax83
fantasia looks a little scary

yeah i wouldnt vote for her. her face is goddamn scary

Originally posted by bubz
hahah yeah i was thinking, wtf i thought i posted in this?

umm diana

yeah go diana

 

[Belle]

I don't really watch this show and I don't really care, but from what I have seen there have been several people kicked out that are ten times better than the two girls left. I don't remember names but there was a heaps good black guy and another girl (she sang circle of life on the Elton John episode) who should still be in there. Therefore out of the two left I don't care to choose.

Stupid Americans.

 

[christ_ine]

Fantasia has the scariest lips, like those candy lips you buy at the stores... OH YAHY RAHNDEEEE!

Yay go Diana!

 

[iambored]

jasmine is crap compared to the other two
both fantasia and diana are pretty and have fantastic voices. fantasia also has a fantastic performance style.

i have finally made up my midn and voted fo rfantasia. i think if diana wins i will be a bit disappointed because she is the run of the mill. fantasia is different.