And the winner is..................... American Idol [FINAL TWO] (2 Viewers)

[Minai]

I dont get it, I totally dont dig Fantasia's whiney, macy gray type voice, but I guess people who know music (the judges) say shes good so she must be good - however, I dislike her voice, it annoys me

 

[jm1234567890]

i will be very disappointed if fantasia wins, besides missy elliot wants to sign her up to do an album, so she is hoping she will lose.

 

[Fry]

stop dissing Fantasia!! she rules!!! yeah sure her voice may sound a little different but she's got a great, vibrant personality and she's the only performer who can sing with so much emotion and makes you really feel something.

although, i agree with some people, i am disappointed with the final two. IMO it should've been Jennifer Hudson and La Toya London, with La Toya being the winner

 

[bubz :D]

i think diana has an awesome voice. did you hear her hold that last note in her last performance? woahhhh.

fantasia can hit the notes too, but like minai, it's just the... tone...? of her voice that i really can't stand. it kinda reminds me of anastasia's voice, i mean i think she's very talented too, but i can't listen to her songs @____@

 

[Collin]

Fantasia really is quite talented. Like people have said, I just can't dig the tone of her voice, but in terms of talent I would personally have to say that Fantasia is better.

Why did Latoya have to get voted off? DAMN HAWAII!

 

[Annegelic]

Originally posted by ~*HSC 4 life*~
they're both prety crap, i'm dissapointed with the final 2

true dat ! BRING BACK LATOYA !! (why don't they chuck a survivor style and actually do that ?? *revenge against america* =P)

 

[Collin]

Originally posted by Annegelic
true dat ! BRING BACK LATOYA !! (why don't they chuck a survivor style and actually do that ?? *revenge against america* =P)

They did that with the likes of Elizabeth Letendre and others for the final 12, so I wouldn't be surprised if they somehow reconjured up Latoya. That girl certainly does deserve another good chance.

 

[Suney_J]

the weird thing is in aussie idol last year, guy and shannon were in the same group in the top 40, and diana and fantasia were in the same in the top 32

Originally posted by Minai
I dont get it, I totally dont dig Fantasia's whiney, macy gray type voice, but I guess people who know music (the judges) say shes good so she must be good - however, I dislike her voice, it annoys me

Originally posted by bubz
fantasia can hit the notes too, but like minai, it's just the... tone...? of her voice that i really can't stand. it kinda reminds me of anastasia's voice, i mean i think she's very talented too, but i can't listen to her songs @____@

she sounds like she doesnt breathe oxygen only helium, but i guess ppl like her cuz she's different

 

[Survivor39]

I am getting Diana's CD if you wins. But not Fantasia's if she wins.

 

[eLmo]

Fantasia will be big if she wins or not... Simon said that Diana needs to win..coz "she's forgettable"

 

[Annegelic]

Originally posted by iambored
jasmine is crap compared to the other two
both fantasia and diana are pretty and have fantastic voices.

fantasia's pretty ? =/

 

[iambored]

Originally posted by Annegelic
fantasia's pretty ? =/

why not?

 

[ay_caramba]

i dont think she's *pretty*, but she's decent, has a good voice and a nice personality
she shud win

 

[Survivor39]

Remember everyone, NO SPOILER on this particular thread, and if you want to make one, use the thread heading spoiler and don't reveal anything in the title. Thank you very much for considering others.

 

[crazyhomo]

Rubin was hella sexy

 

[glycerine]

bahaha, pat, you are so cruel

 

[jm1234567890]

btw, if you don't want to know. i don't suggest you use the internet for 4 days.

 

[crazyhomo]

Originally posted by glycerine
bahaha, pat, you are so cruel

what? just cause you discrimate against plus-size people doesn't make him any less sexy

 

[Seraph]

lets hope this idol is not as snobbish as Kelly Clarkson

 

[iambored]

so someone on this board knows.. i will keep myself in suspense for at least another day