Carr or Brogden? (1 Viewer)

[ohne]

Seeing as though many of us have had a debate on this and we have a Howard versus Latham one, I thought it might also be appropriate to cover things in NSW.

I am with Brogden.

 

[zahid]

Carr....because i am a LABOR man....i also heard him speak at young leaders day...inspirational....hmmm would luv to talk about, and contrast policies but i am tired at the moment.

 

[joujou_84]

carrs a liar and brogden is a whinger.......................
whinger..........liar...........whinger.............liar.............i think whinger.........im with Brogden

 

[lukebennett]

im not just going for brogden because hes a lib but because carr couldnt make nsw anyworse even if he tried. it wouldnt be bad to put brogden in even just for the purpose of a change

 

[lukebennett]

Carr....because i am a LABOR man....i also heard him speak at young leaders day...inspirational....hmmm would luv to talk about, and contrast policies but i am tired at the moment.

might be an inspirational speaker but what hes done for NSW is not inspirational

 

[Generator]

Carr. Against Brogden there can be no real contest, I think, and it also seems as though the Liberals have failed to offer any real alternatives in response to the Government's modest 'reform' agenda.

 

[lukebennett]

all i know is i hate carr but im not sure whether brogden has enough experience

 

[thejosiekiller]

when is the next state and local elections? im finally old enough to vote so i want to learn a lil and have an opinion on the matter

 

[thorrnydevil]

I hate Carr, but I'm not a huge Brogden fan. I'd vote for Brogden over Carr because Carr destroys everything hr touches, eg. The Police Force, Transport

 

[thorrnydevil]

Oh, he also totally fucked up the Health system.

 

[ohne]

when is the next state and local elections? im finally old enough to vote so i want to learn a lil and have an opinion on the matter

not until march 2007. fixed four year terms in nsw with elections being held in march every four years.

 

[zahid]

might be an inspirational speaker but what hes done for NSW is not inspirational

plz explain..

 

[lukebennett]

look at the disastrous state of our transport system-its appaling. look at the state health system, and the police force as thornydevil said. petrol taxes for instance are ridiculously high (particularly compared with queensland). in QLD they pay 8? cents p/L but nSW its about 20 cents higher. i cant see anything good that hes done

 

[thorrnydevil]

look at the disastrous state of our transport system-its appaling. look at the state health system, and the police force as thornydevil said. petrol taxes for instance are ridiculously high (particularly compared with queensland). in QLD they pay 8? cents p/L but nSW its about 20 cents higher. i cant see anything good that hes done

I agree. Carr doesn't deserve to be the Premier. I put foward a vote of no confidence. I wish I could anyway.

 

[lengstar]

It was only this term that Carr's influence in maintaining a State government is rapidly disintegrating and all the policies once gone unnoticed are now highly visible in public eyes.

 

[Scanorama]

Neither, the whole rail systems are completely fucked up by Carrs, so is the Health systems. BUT Brogden and his shadow ministry teams annoy the shit out of me everytime he appears on TV, just the way he looks and the way he talks, even Johnny Howard is better than he does lol. Having said that, Michael Costa is the worst minister I've seen. So Carr will get my vote unless Lib offers someone better than Brogden.

 

[lengstar]

Michael Costa did a good job when overseeing the Police Force did he not?

 

[Ziff]

Carr I think is bored. He needs a new, more stimulating and better job. Broggers is sheer incompetentence...

Luckily - I'll be voting in ACT elections by 2007 so I don't need to worry about this

 

[lukebennett]

i dont necessarily like brogden cause i dont know if he's experienced enough for the job but i really dont like carr. guess they have 3 years to impress me and hopefully my decision will be easier

 

[lukebennett]

I have the feeling Brogden will win next elections. For those who vote for him great im sure he can fix trains and fix hospitals (does anyone think the rail unions will want to work with Brogden?)

When Brogden gets in it will be 'interesting'. Myself, i would much much much prefer Barry O'Farrel... at least he doesnt looke like a fool to anyone who knows anything about state politics.

It is such a pity that the alternative liberal is so...well...hopeless.

its pretty hard when you have to vote for who is least shit