Serius said:
Its not about hurting their little feelings...its mostly subconcious, they did studies on it, if you see red writting all over the work you are proud if telling you are shit you are it can hurt your self esteem. Its a buildup as well, every day you get back peices of work covered in red writing telling you how bad at life you are, it has an effect. No one peice of marked work will upset you but the overall buildup can have an effect in some [admittedly sensitive] people
I agree though that it is a tiny little insigificant problem and no kid is going to have a break down because their work was marked in red, its just one of thousands of little things that schools do wrong, but it is nowhere near the biggest problem and they should be diferting their resources to stop far more significant problems....BUT just because it is a small problem doesnt mean it shouldnt be fixed.
Teachers don't just break out the red to dish out criticism. I know you know that, but just so it's clear that it's probably more about the word choice than the colour pen it's written in. Obviously we need to aim for constructive criticism, I'm not going to write "bullshit effort, fail" on some kid's work (even if that's what I really think of it), BUT I'm not going to sugarcoat it too much either. Sometimes the truth hurts. That's life.
As for the colour of the pen...red is convenient, it's a pretty colour, it's bright and noticeable and I have serious doubts that the continued use of red pen throughout a student's life is going to have any impact at all, positive or negative. It's a total non-issue. If we should be looking to change anything about the way we mark we should probably just be a little more aware of word choice, idk, but pen colour is taking it too far, IMO.
edit: also agree with exphate, etc, that it's a slippery slope to insane amounts of political correctness. No red pen, no black pen (LOL), no X marks or grades, no telling students "no", no doing ANYTHING that makes them feel any less than 110% fizzingly sunshiny and happy.
It's school. You're there to learn. You will make mistakes and fuck up at times otherwise you wouldn't need to go to school in the first place. If the teacher can't even TELL you that you screwed up (in a nicer way of course lol), how are you going to improve?